Tax Decisions - Supreme Court and Revenue Tribunal
A reference index to 23 decisions discussed in the tax and law articles. Each entry identifies the judgment, its relevance and the limits of the comparison. Read the full NKP judgment before relying on a passage in a particular matter.
Inland Revenue Office, Dharan v Bharat Kumar Agrawal, proprietor of Pinky International
NKP decision 11032; case 074-RB-0221 | 2079/10/15 B.S.
The Court upheld cancellation of the FY 2066/67 assessment on the proved procedural and evidential defects.
Limits: Historical FY 2066/67 dispute. It does not exempt unrecorded sales or invalidate every inspection. The tribunal result is reported in the Supreme Court judgment; its separate full text has not been retrieved. No exhaustive subsequent-case search is claimed. The party caption identifies a proprietor; some passages in the judgment call the firm Pvt Ltd. The caption is followed here.
Bhat-Bhateni Supermarket and Departmental Store Pvt Ltd v Director General, Inland Revenue Department and others
NKP decision 11344; case 077-NF-0035 | 2080/10/16 B.S.
The two-to-one majority upheld the historical assessment; Kumar Chudal's proposed reinvestigation was a dissent, not the operative order.
Limits: Historical VAT periods 2064 Shrawan-2067 Magh. Old rates, amounts and limitation wording are not a current calculation guide. The underlying Tribunal judgment is described by the Supreme Court, not separately retrieved. This is not a finding about every non-filing supplier or every later transaction involving the parties.
Inland Revenue Office, Lalitpur v Asia Pacific Communications Associates Nepal Pvt Ltd
NKP decision 10920; 074-RB-0004 | 2078/12/28 B.S.
The Court rejected treating the whole year as the final Ashadh period for limitation, and found no established fraud basis and Departmental reassessment direction supporting the route used. It upheld the Tribunal’s 2070/02/21 reversal of the 2067/03/32 assessment and the 2067/05/31 review decision.
Limits: Historical monthly returns and older quoted statutory wording. This is not an input-credit eligibility ruling or universal bar on fraud reassessment. The Tribunal result is reported through the Supreme Court, not a separately retrieved Tribunal full text. Later-case discovery is bounded; no exhaustive citator claim.
Revenue Tribunal Kathmandu | Decision 298 (2078/79), 076-RB-0019; paragraphs 11-15, PDF 5-7; order PDF 8 | 2079/03/06 B.S.
The majority excluded specified actual salary, travel, bank-commission and rent reimbursements, reversing and remitting for withholding reassessment on the remainder. It rejected the argument that head office and PE cannot transact.
Limits: FY 2070/71; Nepal-Thailand Article 7(3), not India 2011 or universal deduction relief. One member dissented on the appeal-deposit issue. Later appeal status has not been confirmed.
Reasons 2-3 found an effective Tribunal remedy remained and dismissed the writ. Identify the existing appeal and its relationship to the challenged order.
Limits: No ruling that the 100% penalty, interconnection netting or limitation objection was correct. Interim Constitution case; not a universal bar on writs. Tribunal proceeding reported through the Supreme Court judgment only.
Paragraphs 4-6 preserved the 2031 Act assessment/recovery process, including the Tribunal appeal route. Paragraphs 7-8 dismissed the writ for failure to use that available alternative remedy.
Limits: FY 2055/56 dispute. The Court did not decide the claimed aviation exemption or underlying assessment arithmetic on their merits. This is not a universal current-year bypass or collection stay.