Commercial Law

A Person Signs Beyond Their Authority: Enforceability and the Company’s Conduct

A supplier receives a purchase confirmation from a manager, begins work and later discovers that the company disputes the manager's authority. Another business signs a detailed agreement but leaves a legally required formality incomplete. Both disputes show why a signature page is only part of the enforceability enquiry.

On this pageEstablish who is committing the businessAgreement can develop through correspondenceResolve the missing terms before performanceKeep evidence of the bargain that was actually madeJudgments discussedLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Establish who is committing the business

Civil Code section 506(4) addresses contracts on behalf of legal persons through authorised directors or their authorised representatives. In practice, check the company's relevant decision and the signatory's authority for this transaction. A job title, company email address or involvement in negotiations may be relevant evidence, but should not be treated as a substitute for examining authority.

Authority can have limits. A person allowed to request quotations may not have authority to commit the company to a guarantee or long-term purchase. If approval depends on a board decision, financing or a regulator's consent, the agreement should explain whether it is already binding and which obligations depend on that condition.

Civil Code section 596 adds another issue where the company itself led the counterparty reasonably to believe that authority existed. A private instruction limiting a manager may therefore need to be assessed alongside the company’s outward representations. Establish who communicated the limit, what the counterparty knew and whether the company accepted similar transactions before treating the signature as ineffective.

Key points

  • Check the signatory’s authority, the company’s conduct and any required formality alongside the signed agreement.
  • Preserve correspondence and evidence of the bargain actually reached; beginning performance does not remove every authority or enforceability question.

Agreement can develop through correspondence

Civil Code sections 504 and 505 address formation and enforceability, including consent, capacity, lawful obligations and required formalities. They also recognise that contracts need not invariably take the form of a single signed document. This matters where the parties perform first and intend to sign later.

In Nepal Electricity Authority v Nepal Oil Corporation, decision no. 11495 dated 2080/01/11, the Supreme Court treated the parties' correspondence and conduct as a conditional sale contract. The dispute arose under the former Contract Act. Its useful lesson is that a business cannot assume there is no contract merely because the final document was never signed.

That lesson has limits. It does not remove a specific requirement for writing, registration or other formalities. Nor does the judgment establish that every employee's email binds a company. Formation, authority and statutory form must be examined separately.

Resolve the missing terms before performance

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose the supplier's quotation requires advance payment, the buyer's purchase order specifies credit, and an email says only “please proceed”. When a dispute arises, each side may rely on a different document. Assemble the complete exchange and settle the inconsistent term before supply begins.

The same discipline applies to scope, specifications, delivery, acceptance, taxes, cancellation and responsibility for approvals. A contract should explain how amendments become effective and which document prevails when attachments conflict. These are practical drafting measures to reduce uncertainty, rather than a claim that every agreement needs identical clauses.

Keep evidence of the bargain that was actually made

Retain the approved final version, incorporated schedules, authority documents and the communications establishing acceptance. Record later changes and the person authorised to agree them. If performance has already begun under an incomplete agreement, do not quietly replace the historical file with a newly dated document. Identify what happened, preserve the record and obtain advice on how to regularise the continuing arrangement.

A useful contract review asks two connected questions: what has each party legally promised, and what evidence demonstrates that promise? Answering them before a dispute is more valuable than relying on a polished template whose parties, authority or conditions do not fit the transaction.

Judgments discussed

Sources and references

The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.