Commercial Law

An Agent Exceeds Instructions: Internal Limits and Liability to a Third Party

A business may give an agent a strict spending limit internally while presenting that person to customers as having wide authority. If the agent then exceeds the limit, the internal instruction may not answer the customer's claim. The company's own words and conduct towards outsiders can become central evidence.

On this pageSeparate actual authority from the appearance createdApply the rule to a real negotiationState the powers and communicate material limitsThe dispute clause should fit the agency relationshipJudgments discussedLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Separate actual authority from the appearance created

Civil Code section 592 addresses transactions carried out through an agent and the effect of acts beyond authority. Section 596 then deals with a principal who informs a third party, or leads the third party to believe, that the agent is authorised. It includes circumstances in which a reasonable belief may make the principal liable even for an act exceeding the agent's internal authority.

The point is not that every person claiming to be an agent can bind a business. Examine what the principal represented, what the third party knew or reasonably should have known, and the particular transaction. An internal limit and an outward representation should be considered together.

Key points

  • Separate an agent’s internal instructions from the authority the business appears to give that person towards third parties.
  • Preserve the company’s communications and conduct, and communicate material limits where needed; an undisclosed spending cap may not settle an outsider’s claim.

Apply the rule to a real negotiation

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose a distributor introduces its representative as the person handling all dealer contracts, repeatedly accepts orders negotiated by that representative, and allows the representative to use standard company documents. The representative later promises an unusual rebate beyond an internal limit. The company should not assume that producing the private instruction alone resolves the dispute.

The dealer must still establish the relevant facts and reasonable basis for believing authority existed. A conspicuously unusual commitment or an express notice that board approval is required can change the analysis. The legal question is therefore more precise than whether the representative's name appears on the payroll.

State the powers and communicate material limits

The appointment should identify the transactions the agent may undertake, financial limits, signing powers, receipt of money, use of sub-agents and the method for seeking approval. Section 593 separately addresses sub-agency and consent. A broad permission to “manage sales” should not leave the parties guessing whether it includes borrowing, guarantees or appointing another representative.

Material limits also need appropriate communication to those who deal with the agent. When the appointment ends, review outstanding transactions, access to company documents and the notices required for the circumstances. Merely recovering an identification card may leave counterparties relying on an earlier representation.

The dispute clause should fit the agency relationship

In Nepal Airlines Corporation's dispute concerning Harati Travels, decision no. 8523 dated 2067/04/17, the Supreme Court considered claims connected with a sales-agency agreement. Actual bank expenses arising from dishonoured cheques were treated as falling within the agreement's arbitration scope. The case illustrates how an agency relationship can generate connected claims beyond the headline commission or sale amount.

It does not decide modern Civil Code apparent-authority liability. For that question, begin with sections 592 and 596 and the actual representations. Keep the appointment, approval records, customer communications, invoices and money trail together. They reveal both what the agent was told and what the business allowed others reasonably to understand.

Judgments discussed

Sources and references

The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.