Company Law

A Shareholder Demands Company Records: Identify the Access Right and Its Scope

A shareholder asks for “all company documents”, including bank records, board papers and another shareholder’s correspondence. The company refuses everything on confidentiality grounds. Both positions are too broad: the access right depends on the company type, the particular record and the statutory provision relied on.

On this pageName the record and the legal rightDistinguish inspection, copies and a transaction statementConsider a practical disputeAccess and a remedy are different stepsJudgments discussedLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Name the record and the legal right

Section 146 of the Companies Act 2063 gives a private-company shareholder, or the shareholder’s representative, inspection rights during office hours over specified records. These include general-meeting and board minute books, annual financial statements, the share register and company accounts. Directors and officers must arrange sufficient access to those documents.

This is a significant right. It should not be reduced to receiving a short management summary. Equally, the section should not be quoted as a universal public-company right to inspect every internal document. Other rights, including the share-register provisions in section 46, have their own scope and conditions.

Key points

  • Identify the particular record, company type and statutory access right before accepting an unrestricted demand or refusing everything as confidential.
  • Distinguish inspection, obtaining copies and seeking a legal remedy, keeping the request and response within the relevant right.

Distinguish inspection, copies and a transaction statement

Section 46 addresses register inspection, permitted closure arrangements and copies subject to the applicable fee. A temporary statutory closure is different from an indefinite refusal. Where a company relies on closure, the relevant dates, notice and legal basis should be identified.

For a private company, section 147 separately allows a shareholder to request a statement of transactions for a financial year. The provision requires the relevant responsible person to supply it within 15 days, including certified annual financial statements. It is useful to specify the year requested so the company can respond to the correct statutory request.

Consider a practical dispute

An investor in a private company suspects that director expenses have increased sharply. A focused request identifies the financial year, company accounts and board minutes relevant to those payments, and provides the representative’s authority where someone else will inspect.

The company should identify the records it holds, arrange inspection and record what was made available. If a requested item falls outside the stated provision, explain that issue specifically rather than using the unrelated item to refuse access to records clearly covered.

An inspection record should preserve who attended, the dates and documents provided. It need not imply that the shareholder accepted the accounts or waived an objection.

Access and a remedy are different steps

In NKP 10277, dated 2075/09/16, Purna Man Maharjan v Vishal Bazaar Company, the Supreme Court discussed statutory shareholder remedies and criticised using exceptional procedural difficulties to prolong corporate paralysis. The case concerned government investment and an obstructed AGM; it did not decide every records-access dispute.

Its limited practical relevance is that a shareholder should identify the actual statutory remedy and supporting facts. A refusal to provide accounts, suspected misuse of money and failure to call a meeting are related concerns, but may require different legal routes.

Keep the written request, delivery evidence, replies and inspection arrangements. A precise record of what was sought and withheld provides a clearer basis for further action than a general assertion that the company is secretive.

Judgments discussed

Sources and references

The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.