Establish what actually happened
Separate three questions: whether a meeting took place, whether the people attending could decide the matter, and whether the person signing could implement that decision. A signed attendance sheet answers only the first question. An email from a director may explain the discussion without establishing a board decision.
Section 97(7) of the Companies Act 2063 requires a separate record of attendance, matters discussed and board decisions. It also addresses signatures on the minutes. For a private company, begin with its articles under section 97(1), together with applicable statutory requirements. Founders appointing the initial directors under section 87 does not itself authorise every later borrowing or guarantee.
Collect the notice, agenda, meeting papers, correspondence, original drafts and any contemporaneous instructions to the bank. Check the directors holding office at that time. A later appointment cannot silently repair an earlier absence of authority.
Key points
- Distinguish an authorised decision that was poorly recorded from a decision that was never made by the competent body.
- Reconstruct the chronology from genuine evidence and follow the proper correction route. A document prepared today should not be backdated to create earlier authority.
Distinguish a missing record from a missing decision
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Suppose three directors attended and unanimously approved a particular loan, but the clerk omitted the amount from the minutes. That is different from a manager agreeing terms before any board discussion. The first problem concerns recording evidence of a decision; the second concerns whether the company authorised the transaction at all.
If the board now considers a correction, the record should state when the correction is made, the evidence examined and precisely what it corrects. Where a fresh approval is required, record it as a fresh approval. Whether later ratification can validate an earlier act depends on the company’s powers, the competent approving body and rights already created. It is not a general cure for prohibited conduct.
Authority remains a separate legal issue
In NKP decision 11022, dated 2079/09/06, Khampache/P.S. JV v a director of Jalap Nepal, the Supreme Court examined whether a director’s settlement could bind the company. Its reasoning in paragraphs 5-12 connected corporate authority with the purpose for which it was given. On the particular contract and evidence, the disputed settlement did not bind the company as alleged.
That decision supports checking the signatory’s authority under section 104. It does not establish that every imperfect minute invalidates an otherwise authorised transaction.
Build a usable correction file
Keep the original record intact, the proposed correction, supporting evidence and the decision approving the correction together. Identify any bank, shareholder or regulator document that also needs correction. If directors disagree about what happened, preserve that disagreement rather than producing a unanimous account unsupported by the evidence.
A reliable minute book records corporate decisions. It should not become a reconstruction designed merely to satisfy a lender’s checklist.
Judgments discussed
- Khampache/P.S. JV v director of Jalap Nepal Pvt. Ltd. - Decision No. 11022
Judgment: 2079/09/06 B.S. · 5-12, 23. Finding and limits.
Sources and references
The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.