Disclosure is the beginning of the analysis
Section 92 of the Companies Act 2063 addresses directors’ disclosures. In particular, section 92(4) requires prompt information about the nature and extent of a direct or indirect interest in an existing or proposed transaction involving the company or its subsidiary.
The disclosure should identify the actual relationship and commercial interest. Saying “the parties are related” leaves unanswered whether the director owns shares, receives a commission, controls the supplier or has a close-relative connection. Keep the relevant contract and ownership information with the disclosure.
Key points
- Disclosure of a director’s interest does not by itself resolve participation, approval authority or any additional shareholder-approval requirement.
- Record the relationship, exclusions, competent decision-maker and commercial basis, applying the rules for the actual company and transaction.
Participation and approval require their own answers
Section 97(6) prevents a director from participating in the discussion or vote on a matter involving personal interest. The decision record should show how this restriction was applied. The director signing a disclosure and then approving the contract alone creates an obvious issue; the disclosure does not cancel the participation rule.
Section 93 contains additional approval provisions for significant related-party transactions involving public companies, together with statutory conditions and exceptions. It should not be presented as a universal approval formula for every private company. Company type, articles, transaction characteristics and the specific statutory route must be examined.
Work through the commercial facts
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Suppose a director recommends a relative’s maintenance business. The price is competitive and the work is needed urgently. Those facts can support the commercial rationale, but do not establish approval authority. The company should preserve the scope, pricing comparison, relationship disclosure and decision by the competent unconflicted body.
If the contract has already been performed, identify what was authorised, what was supplied, who benefited and whether the company suffered loss. Retrospectively dating a disclosure would obscure the real chronology and make the record less dependable.
What the court’s authority analysis adds
In NKP 11022, dated 2079/09/06, concerning Khampache/P.S. JV and Jalap Nepal, the Supreme Court linked corporate authority to its proper purpose and the company’s interests. It did not decide that a director’s title alone validates every transaction. The reasoning supports examining authority as well as the commercial result.
Sections 99(4)-(5) separately address good faith, care and recovery of loss from bad-faith conduct. A profitable transaction and an undisclosed conflict are therefore not automatically the same question, just as a disclosed conflict does not make an unauthorised transaction lawful.
Keep the evidence sufficient to explain the decision
The file should allow a reader to identify the interest, the governing approval rule, the participants excluded, the authorised signatory and the commercial basis. If a dispute arises, the remedy depends on the breached provision and resulting harm; there is no single automatic consequence for every related-party contract.
Judgments discussed
- Khampache/P.S. JV v director of Jalap Nepal Pvt. Ltd. - Decision No. 11022
Judgment: 2079/09/06 B.S. · 5-12, 23. Finding and limits.
Sources and references
Companies Act 2063, sections 92-93,97(6),99; Ministry consolidation through Chaitra2081.
NKP 11022,2079/09/06, paragraphs 5-12; authority and fiduciary-duty reasoning.
The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.