Bhat-Bhateni VAT judgment: false invoices, evidence and the limitation exception

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

A two-to-one Full Bench majority upheld the historical assessment on the false-invoice evidence; Justice Kumar Chudal dissented.

What the dispute concerned

Decision 11344, dated 2080/10/16, concerned VAT periods from 2064 Shrawan to 2067 Magh. The case examined alleged false purchase invoices used to claim input credit. It was not simply a missing-particulars dispute. The majority read supplier statements, registration and filing information, purchase records and other evidence, including a supplier's denial of the purported transactions. The majority upheld the assessment and the earlier judicial outcomes.

Why the limitation argument failed

Paragraphs 3-5 distinguish the ordinary section 20(4) limitation from section 20(4क), which permits Department-directed reassessment where false documents or fraud have been used to evade tax. The record showed a Director General permission and work order. The Court applied that special exception to the proved circumstances. Do not turn this into a rule that an officer can label any difference fraud and ignore limitation, or copy the judgment's historical ordinary-clock wording into a current advice note.

Key points

  • The officer's evidential burden coexists with the buyer's duty to prove a qualifying input-credit claim.
  • The fraud exception does not mean every ordinary assessment has unlimited time.

What evidence each side needed

Paragraph 8 explains the officer's burden in the context of the taxpayer's self-assessment duties. The Department still had to establish its allegation. The buyer, however, had to support credit under section 17 and the prescribed documents. The Court found that the investigation established the false-invoice case and that the taxpayer did not substantiate the disputed supplies. The lesson is to connect supplier identity, invoice, actual supply, stock movement and payment, not to rely on a document's appearance alone.

Read the holding within its limits

The Court also considered the historical penalty and the actual opportunity to respond. Paragraphs 22-23 warn against using precedents from materially different facts and statutory settings merely because they concern tax. A supplier's later non-filing, standing alone, should not be presented as reproducing all the findings in this case. For a current dispute, identify the precise allegation, original evidence, applicable law and relevant procedural record before drawing the same conclusion.

Directive illustration: an invoice without a supply

Chapter 9.2.3 lists knowingly claiming through false invoices, deliberately claiming the same invoice more than once and issuing an invoice without supplying goods or services. This unnumbered passage specifies no taxpayer, year or amount. It explains conduct requiring factual examination; it is not a numerical example from the Bhat-Bhateni judgment.

Source: IRD VAT Directives 2069 Third Amendment 2080

Current legal position

The relevant section 17(1), (6) entitlement/documentation rules and section 20(3)-(4क) burden/limitation provisions show no material four-year change in the official consolidations through 2082 and Finance 2083 overlay. This article does not reproduce current section 29 penalty rates. Rule 39 documents were checked through the 27th Rules and 28th overlay.

Bhat-Bhateni Supermarket and Departmental Store Pvt Ltd v Director General, Inland Revenue Department and others

Court: Supreme Court of Nepal, Full Bench

Citation: NKP decision 11344; case 077-NF-0035

Decision date: 2080/10/16

Issue: False-invoice input credits, the section 20(4क) fraud exception, the assessment evidential burden and the historical penalty.

Holding: The two-to-one majority upheld the assessment and prior judicial decisions in paragraph 24. It applied section 20(4क), found the Department had established the false-invoice allegation, and assessed the taxpayer's credit-documentation duties alongside the officer's burden. Justice Kumar Chudal dissented: he considered the investigation incomplete and would have required fresh investigation and reassessment concerning filer suppliers within six months. That proposed direction was the minority view, not the operative order.

Relevance: An invoice alone does not answer evidence of a fictitious supply; the limitation exception and its Departmental authority require a fact-specific analysis.

Limits: Historical VAT periods 2064 Shrawan-2067 Magh. Old rates, amounts and limitation wording are not a current calculation guide. The underlying Tribunal judgment is described by the Supreme Court, not separately retrieved. This is not a finding about every non-filing supplier or every later transaction involving the parties.

Read the official decision

Sources and references