Define the disputes and the process
The Arbitration Act, 2055 recognises written arbitration agreements and provides the statutory framework for covered disputes. A clause should identify its intended scope and explain how the tribunal is appointed. The Act supplies rules where the agreement does not resolve particular matters, but an incomplete clause can still create avoidable disagreement.
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Consider a supply-and-installation contract with separate documents for maintenance and payment security. If each contains a different dispute clause, a claim arising across them may lead to an argument about which forum can decide what. Review the related documents together rather than copy the arbitration wording into each independently.
Key points
- Define the disputes covered, appointment mechanism and procedure while the parties can still agree on them.
- Read the arbitration clause with the governing law and permitted court involvement; later court review is not simply a fresh hearing of the merits.
Clarify procedure without promising a result
Arbitrator number and appointment, place, language and the agreed procedural rules are practical matters to settle. Check how any proposed institutional rules fit the contract and statutory requirements. A reference to expedited proceedings should be considered deliberately; the Ministry's amended Act includes provision for expedited arbitration by agreement, but the label alone does not guarantee a quick or inexpensive outcome.
The clause should also address the parties' contact details and notices consistently. A sound clause is not a reason to ignore a claim when it arrives. Preserve the appointment papers, pleadings, notices and jurisdiction decisions, and obtain advice promptly on any objection or applicable deadline.
Court review is not a fresh merits hearing
In Kanchanjunga Tamang Joint Venture v Appellate Court Patan and others, decision no. 11322 dated 2080/11/17, the Supreme Court held that the award-review court must stay within the statutory grounds rather than rehear individual claims as an appeal on the merits. It also examined the failure to raise an earlier jurisdiction objection and the absence of objective grounds establishing excess jurisdiction.
The Court quashed the order sending the award back and directed payment under the award. This does not mean jurisdiction can never be challenged or that every arbitral decision is immune. It means an unsuccessful party must identify the proper legal ground, not merely ask the court to prefer a different factual conclusion.
Scope can include connected claims
In the older Nepal Airlines Corporation dispute involving Harati Travels, decision no. 8523 dated 2067/04/17, actual bank expenses arising from dishonoured cheques were treated as connected with the sales-agency agreement and within the arbitration's scope. The useful point is to read the claim and agreement together; the case is not permission to send every unrelated dispute to arbitration.
Both judgments must be read in their statutory and factual context. The Ministry consolidation consulted includes amendments through end-Ashwin 2082, later than the decisions. For a live dispute, examine that applicable law, the exact clause and procedural history together. Careful drafting reduces uncertainty, while careful participation preserves the ability to raise the right issue at the right stage.
Judgments discussed
- Nepal Airlines Corporation / Harati agency arbitration - Decision No. 8523
Judgment: 2067/04/17 B.S. · operative arbitration reasoning. Finding and limits. - Kanchanjunga Tamang JV v Appellate Court, Patan - Decision No. 11322
Judgment: 2080/11/17 B.S. · award-review reasoning. Finding and limits.
Sources and references
The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.