Investment and Business Regulation

A Registered Company Uses Someone Else’s Brand: Company Name and Trademark Rights Differ

A business can have an incorporated company, an active website and printed packaging while its claim to a brand remains unsettled. Those records identify the business or show use; they do not replace the trademark process. The difficult question often arises when another trader applies for the same or a similar mark.

On this pageIdentify the right that needs protectionAn earlier application is not the entire answerBuild evidence for the actual disputeMatch the registration to the businessJudgments discussedLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Identify the right that needs protection

Section 16 of the Patent, Design and Trade Mark Act, 2022 links trademark title to registration under the Act. Section 18 provides for examination and registration. A company-name record therefore answers a different question from a trademark certificate issued under that process.

The distinction becomes important in a group. A holding company may own the mark, an operating company may sell the goods, and a distributor may control the website. The parties should establish who owns the registered right and on what basis the others use it. Section 21D provides a statutory process for transfer or permission to use; a private brand agreement should be checked against it.

Key points

  • Company incorporation, brand use and trademark protection establish different things.
  • Match the claimed mark, application history and business use to the relevant dispute; an earlier application alone may not answer every issue.

An earlier application is not the entire answer

In Sun Fitting Pvt Ltd and Department of Industry v Sandeep Industries, decision no. 10304, dated 2075/03/32, the Supreme Court examined competing claims over the SUN mark. The Department had relied on the earlier application without adequately examining the objection and relevant evidence. The Court upheld the remittal for a reasoned decision.

This was not a ruling that the foreign claimant automatically owned the Nepal mark. Its practical importance is narrower: when a credible objection has been raised, filing first does not excuse the authority from examining the legally relevant evidence. Equally, a business should not treat its own application receipt as a final certificate of an uncontested right.

Build evidence for the actual dispute

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose a manufacturer adopts a name already used abroad and then receives an objection after applying in Nepal. The enquiry may require the goods or services concerned, competing marks, Nepal use, foreign registration evidence, claimed priority and the statutory grounds for objection. A general claim that “our company name was approved” does not address those matters.

Keep the application, specimens, class details, publication, objection and response together. Preserve dated evidence of actual use and the source of design work. If a foreign registration or international protection is relied on, identify the precise legal basis; do not assume that foreign registration alone supplies every Nepal right.

Match the registration to the business

Section 18A addresses classification and separate applications for different goods or services categories. A certificate should therefore be read for the mark, proprietor and category it actually covers. Expansion into another product or service may warrant further assessment.

Ownership changes, licences and renewal status also deserve attention before a sale, franchise or financing transaction. A brand can have considerable commercial value while its legal file contains an expired certificate or an unrecorded transfer. Resolving that discrepancy before the transaction is usually easier than arguing about who promised what after completion. Brand protection depends on the relevant statutory right and evidence, rather than the number of places a business has printed its name.

Judgments discussed

Sources and references

The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.