Labour Law

Fixed-term Contracts Keep Renewing: When the Work and the Contract No Longer Match

An employee signs a new six-month contract every time the previous one ends, while performing the same continuing work. The employer relies on the expiry date; the employee says the role is regular. The dispute cannot be resolved simply by counting contracts or reading their headings.

On this pageThe Act recognises different kinds of employmentCompare the contract with the actual assignmentExpiry rules require the right classification firstPrepare the evidence before deciding the exitJudgments discussedLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

The Act recognises different kinds of employment

Section 10 of the Labour Act 2074 distinguishes regular, work-based, time-based, casual and part-time employment. Time-based employment specifies a period in which services or work are to be provided. But section 10(2) directs that a dispute over regular employment is determined from the nature of the work, notwithstanding the contract’s wording.

Labour Rules 2075, rule 3, adds relevant inquiry factors. These include whether the work must continue after the stated period and whether another worker is immediately needed to continue it. The rule also addresses regular work exceeding a year where no completion period was specified. These are factual tests, not a universal rule that any repeated contract automatically becomes permanent.

Key points

  • Compare the repeated contract terms with the nature and continuity of the actual work before deciding the employment category.
  • Analyse expiry or exit only after that classification; repeated signatures or an expiry heading cannot settle the question alone.

Compare the contract with the actual assignment

Consider two different arrangements. One employee is engaged to process documents for a defined project that genuinely ends. Another runs the company’s ordinary receivables function continuously, with successive employees or contracts covering the same ongoing need.

Both contracts may contain identical expiry clauses. Their work and operational circumstances differ. The file should explain the project or temporary requirement, what changed at each renewal, and whether the function continued after the employee’s stated end date.

Rule 4 also requires the contract to identify employment type, main duties, position and effective date, alongside the Act’s remuneration and conditions requirements. An accurate description helps; inserting a fixed-term label without the supporting facts does not settle classification.

Expiry rules require the right classification first

Section 140 addresses termination on completion of the agreed period or work for the relevant categories. Its project-work proviso also matters where the work or completion period is extended. Do not assume an expiry clause takes effect independently of what happened to the underlying assignment.

In NKP 11304, dated 2080/03/20, Khimti Project School v Labour Court and Sangita Ban, the Supreme Court quashed reinstatement in a fixed-term primary-teacher dispute. Paragraphs 13-15 discussed the agreed term and sections 10 and 140. The Court also relied on the school’s educational-trust, education-law and service-manual context.

That qualification is essential. The case does not give every employer permission to use serial contracts for any continuing role, nor does it erase the nature-of-work inquiry under section 10(2).

Prepare the evidence before deciding the exit

Retain every contract, renewal, job description, project schedule, payroll record and communication about continuing work. Identify the applicable sector law as well as the Labour Act. If the parties disagree over classification, the Rules provide a determination route; presenting the dispute as merely an unsigned renewal can conceal the legal question that needs resolution.

Judgments discussed

Sources and references

The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.