Labour Law

Probation Ends Without a Decision: The Employment Position and the Evidence

An employee finishes the contractual probation period and continues working, but no confirmation letter is issued. Months later, the employer proposes ending the appointment “during probation”. The missing letter is evidence to examine; it is not automatically permission to extend probation indefinitely.

On this pageApply the current statutory ruleSeparate assessment from the authorised decisionRead the historical case with its legal limitsDecide the next step on the real employment positionJudgments discussedLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Apply the current statutory rule

Section 13 of the Labour Act 2074 permits an employment contract to provide for six months’ probation. If the work is unsatisfactory, the employer may terminate during that period. Where employment has not been terminated, the section provides that the employment relationship stands valid after probation ends.

The employment contract, actual commencement date, any earlier work and the decision chronology therefore matter more than the date on a late confirmation letter. A label such as provisional appointment cannot displace statutory minimum standards under section 3.

There is a further distinction for trainees. The proviso to section 18(4) states that probation does not apply when the same employer engages the trainee in work after training. Establish what the earlier arrangement actually was before adding another trial period.

Key points

  • Establish the employee’s actual position under the current probation rule before relying on a missing confirmation letter.
  • Keep the performance assessment, authorised decision and communication distinct; a historical case must be read within its earlier legal context.

Separate assessment from the authorised decision

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose a supervisor completes an adverse assessment before probation ends, but the person authorised to decide does nothing until after expiry. The assessment records an opinion about performance. It does not necessarily establish that employment was terminated during probation.

The company should identify who could decide, when the decision was made, when it was communicated and whether the employee continued working. A document prepared after the event should state its actual date; backdating a termination letter would conceal the issue rather than answer it.

Read the historical case with its legal limits

In NKP 7849, dated 2064/03/20, Casino Royal/N.R.C. Pvt Ltd v Labour Court and Laxmi Dangal, the Supreme Court dismissed the employer’s challenge to the employee’s reinstatement. The judgment distinguished a supervisor’s assessment from the decision of the competent appointing authority and rejected the attempted continuation of trial after the relevant statutory service period.

That case applied the repealed Labour Act 2048, including its 240-day service test. It is not authority for using 240 days as the present probation period. Its relevant lesson is narrower: the evidence must establish a lawful, timely decision by the competent person. Today’s starting point is section 13 of the 2074 Act.

Decide the next step on the real employment position

After probation has ended, a performance concern must be assessed under the legal route that actually applies. It should not be relabelled an unfinished probation exercise merely because management omitted the confirmation paperwork. The available process may involve performance management or another lawful ground, with its own requirements.

Keep the original contract, attendance and payroll commencement records, training documents, assessments and communications together. Correct the personnel record to reflect the actual position. A confirmation letter can record that position clearly, but cannot lawfully create an extra probation period contrary to the governing rule.

Judgments discussed

Sources and references

The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.