VAT appeals: the Revenue Tribunal, Supreme Court permission and filing evidence

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 3 November 2026

Identify the appealable decision and preserve its service record.

Identify the route and its trigger

VAT section 32 permits Tribunal appeal against the specified Director General suspension order or administrative-review decision. Section 31क(5) separately permits appeal when review remains undecided after 60 days. Keep that non-decision route distinct from an appeal against a served decision. Under Tribunal Act section 9(4), the ordinary Tribunal deadline is 35 days from hearing the decision or service of its notice. Record the applicable trigger; do not assume every stage starts on the assessment date.

Prepare the VAT deposit and papers

Section 33 requires undisputed tax to be paid and 50% of disputed tax and penalty to be deposited or covered by bank guarantee. Its calculation includes the qualifying one-quarter tax deposited for administrative review. Reconcile the actual remaining amount, rather than automatically paying another 50%. Attach the prescribed Treasury deposit voucher in the relevant office's name or the bank guarantee with the appeal.

Rule 34 requires the relevant period's return before appealing the Rule 29 assessment. Preserve decisions, service evidence, grounds, supporting documents and payment records. Section 32(2) also requires written information to the Department, with an appeal copy, within 15 days of registration. Keep proof of that separate notification. Routine filing and record duties continue while a dispute is pending.

Key points

  • For a VAT appeal, use the specific VAT deposit provision and credit qualifying review deposits.
  • Supreme Court permission is a separate legal stage; permission does not cure a late application.

Separate Supreme Court permission from a second appeal

Tribunal Act section 8 requires Supreme Court permission based on a direct legal error capable of reversing the decision wholly or partly: jurisdiction, improper handling of evidence, breach of mandatory procedure or serious legal error. Disagreement alone does not create an unrestricted second appeal. Preserve the certified judgment and grounds and check the applicable permission deadline and court procedure promptly. The historical Ujjwal Polythene case shows that even permission already granted cannot cure an out-of-time application.

Keep exceptional relief and payment effects separate

The constitutional writ route has distinct grounds, including the adequacy and effectiveness of an alternative remedy for ordinary legal rights; it is not a routine replacement for a missed appeal. Section 26 continues interest during review or appeal. Read any interim order for its actual effect instead of assuming the dispute suspends every collection step.

C.M. & Associates illustration: VAT Tribunal deposit

Assume disputed VAT of Rs 400,000 and penalty of Rs 100,000, undisputed tax already paid, and Rs 100,000 qualifying review deposit. Under VAT section 33, 50% of Rs 500,000 is Rs 250,000; the remaining cover is Rs 150,000. This illustrates the VAT provision, not the general Tribunal formula or a Supreme Court filing fee.

Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.

Current legal position

The 2081 Tribunal amendment expressly adds an unconditional bank guarantee renewable through the case; VAT section 33 already had its own guarantee route. The historical Directive must be read with these specific provisions. Permission and non-decision appeal deadlines need their own case-record checks.

VAT section 33(2): one-quarter wording

Before: The checked Act through Finance 2081 referred to the twenty-five percent tax deposited for administrative review.

Change: The words twenty-five percent are replaced by one quarter. The amount remains mathematically the same.

Instrument: Finance Act 2082 section 35(8), original PDF page 13.

Effective date: Immediately under section 1(2), expressly including section 35; Gazette 2082/03/30, PDF page 1.

Practical effect: Count the qualifying review deposit in the Tribunal requirement. This wording change does not demand a second full deposit.

Tribunal Act section 9(1): bank guarantee wording

Before: The earlier general Tribunal wording required deposit without expressly offering the alternative added here. VAT section 33 separately already allowed a bank guarantee.

Change: The general wording now expressly permits deposit or an unconditional bank guarantee capable of renewal throughout the case. The amendment does not replace the VAT-specific deposit calculation.

Instrument: Business Environment/Investment Amendment Ordinance 2081 section 3, original PDF page 5; replacement Act 2081 section 3, original PDF page 4. Act section 13, PDF page 35, repeals the Ordinance and saves acts done under it.

Effective date: Ordinance immediate under section 1(2), PDF page 2, Gazette 2081/09/29; replacement Act immediate under section 1(2), PDF page 2, Gazette 2081/12/18.

Practical effect: Check the guarantee's conditions and coverage and the actual applicable statutory route; the amendment is not an appeal-deposit waiver.

Inland Revenue Office Kathmandu Area No. 3 v Tara Dhungana, proprietor of Ujjwal Polythene Industry

Court: Supreme Court of Nepal, Division Bench

Citation: NKP 2080, issue 8, decision 11152; 071-RB-0158

Decision date: 2078/09/12

Issue: Whether an already permitted revenue appeal survived when its permission application was late.

Holding: The Court treated office receipt of the judgment with the taxpayer's 2068/08/02 implementation request as knowledge. The permission application of 2068/11/19 exceeded the then applicable 35-day period and historical extension framework. It dismissed the appeal despite earlier permission, without entering the Tribunal judgment's merits.

Relevance: Preserve actual knowledge/service records and check limitation independently of permission.

Limits: FY 2055/56 VAT and a Tribunal judgment dated 2058/09/25; then applicable Muluki Ain procedure. Historical extension rules are not silently applied to current filings. The SC did not decide current recycled-plastic exemption or the merits of that historical tax assessment. Underlying Tribunal outcome reported through SC only.

Read the official decision

A VAT appeal is pending: assess a parallel writ separately

A writ is an exceptional constitutional remedy, not a second ordinary VAT appeal.

Identify what the new order actually changes

A taxpayer may already be challenging an assessment when the office issues another order. Compare the decisions and relief sought before selecting the next remedy. Under the VAT Act, administrative review, Tribunal appeal and a review left undecided after 60 days have separate statutory routes. An objection to a later order does not itself erase the existing proceeding or its filing conditions.

Separate constitutional jurisdiction from the merits

Article 133(2)-(3) of the present Constitution provides extraordinary jurisdiction for fundamental rights, specified ordinary legal rights and public-interest questions. For ordinary legal rights, the text addresses absence of another remedy or its inadequacy or ineffectiveness. This is not a rule that every VAT dispute must obtain a writ, or that a statutory appeal always excludes constitutional relief. The grounds and effectiveness of the available remedy need individual assessment.

The Nepal Doorsanchar decision below arose under the Interim Constitution. Use it for its actual procedural setting, rather than treating it as a decision on every present constitutional exception. Keep the requested interim protection separate from final relief. Current VAT section 26 expressly continues interest during administrative review or appeal; filing a challenge does not itself establish the terms of a stay.

Key points

  • A procedural dismissal does not decide the disputed VAT calculation.
  • Preserve the statutory remedy while examining any distinct constitutional ground.

C.M. & Associates illustration: two different questions

A business disputes both an assessed amount and a later enforcement step. Whether a court will hear an extraordinary petition is separate from whether the assessment is correct. Identify the challenged order, available statutory remedy and precise protection sought; do not report refusal of one remedy as approval of the tax calculation.

Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.

Current legal position

Use the current Constitution and the procedure applicable to the actual order. This historical judgment does not waive statutory deadlines or determine a current penalty rate.

Nepal Doorsanchar Company v Large Taxpayer Office and others

Court: Supreme Court of Nepal, Division Bench

Citation: NKP 2071, issue 10, decision 9265; 069-WO-1243

Decision date: 2071/07/09

Issue: A writ against a later VAT penalty while the related statutory appeal was pending.

Holding: Reasons 2-3 found an effective Tribunal remedy remained and dismissed the writ.

Relevance: Identify the existing appeal and its relationship to the challenged order.

Limits: No ruling that the 100% penalty, interconnection netting or limitation objection was correct. Interim Constitution case; not a universal bar on writs. Tribunal proceeding reported through the Supreme Court judgment only.

Read the official decision

Sources and references