Old income-tax years: what repeal saved and which appeal route survives
Prepared by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants
Repeal did not erase assessments and recovery for income years governed by the old Income Tax Act 2031.
Continuity and the old-year saving do different work
Section 143(1) repealed the Income Tax Act 2031 and House and Land Rent Tax Act 2023. Subsection (3) treats acts and proceedings under the repealed or amended enactments identified in subsections (1)-(2) as acts under the 2058 Act. That continuity rule prevents repeal alone from wiping away what was done.
Subsection (4) separately preserves the 2031 Act’s provisions for assessment and recovery of income tax for income years before the 2058 Act applied. Do not replace that specific saving with a general assumption that every demand issued today uses today’s assessment procedure. Equally, the saving does not itself announce a new assessment deadline or cancel the tax.
The remedy belongs to the saved assessment process
In Manakamana Airways, the disputed assessment concerned FY 2055/56, although the assessment order was issued after the new Act commenced. The Supreme Court held that the saved assessment process included the appeal route. It recognised the old Act’s alternative statutory remedies rather than requiring the new Act’s administrative-review gateway for that historical assessment. The writ was dismissed because the alternative Tribunal remedy had not been used.
An incorrect appeal direction in a notice did not extinguish the remedy created by statute. This is a historical transition ruling, not permission to bypass administrative review for an ordinary current-year assessment, and not an automatic stay of collection.
Key points
- The year of the income and the saved procedure matter; the date printed on a later demand does not alone choose the law.
Keep the transition boundary specific
Directive 32.12 treats FY 2058/59 under the new Act and explains separate transition questions for fees, interest, exemptions and older documents. Rule 40 similarly saves acts under the repealed 2039 Rules. Continuity does not make every old form or exemption permanently current.
For an old dispute, identify the income year, the liability being assessed and the particular saved remedy before applying a current rate or procedure. A newer deduction, tax credit or appeal condition cannot simply be imported into a year governed by the old law. Separate income-tax liability from any fee or interest calculation spanning commencement; those components require their own applicable provisions.
Directive transition illustration - a newer deduction does not rewrite an old year
Paragraph 32.12(10) explains that an amount not deductible or creditable for a year governed by the 2031 Act does not become allowable merely because the 2058 Act later commenced. It cites advertising or entertainment expenditure beyond the old permitted limit and a medical-treatment tax credit. Conversely, a new inclusion rule is not automatically applied to income excluded under the old year’s law. The source supplies no numbered rupee calculation.
Current legal position
Section 143(3)-(4) remains the statutory starting point for this historical boundary. This article does not establish that a particular decades-old assessment remains timely, unpaid or enforceable. The ordinary current-year assessment and review rules remain separate.
Manakamana Airways Pvt. Ltd., through managing director Kishor Silwal v Ministry of Finance and others
Court: Supreme Court, joint bench
Citation: NKP Decision 8305, writ 2061 No. 2827
Decision date: 2066/06/26
Issue: Whether the section 143(4) saving for an old income-year assessment includes the old statutory appeal route.
Holding: Paragraphs 4-6 preserved the 2031 Act assessment/recovery process, including the Tribunal appeal route. Paragraphs 7-8 dismissed the writ for failure to use that available alternative remedy.
Relevance: The historical income year, not simply the later assessment date, determined the saved procedural route.
Limits: FY 2055/56 dispute. The Court did not decide the claimed aviation exemption or underlying assessment arithmetic on their merits. This is not a universal current-year bypass or collection stay.