Separate payment from allocation
Section 85 of the Income Tax Act requires payment in the prescribed place and manner. A banking receipt is evidence that money moved, but the taxpayer also needs to connect the payment with the correct tax account and liability.
Prepare a comparison showing the intended taxpayer details and the details actually used. Include the amount, value date, transaction reference, revenue heading and tax period. Retain the bank statement, payment instruction and original voucher. If a payer or representative made the error, obtain their written explanation and the records needed to trace the instruction.
Key points
- Trace the payment’s PAN, revenue heading and period before paying again or assuming an offset is available.
- Distinguish a missing credit, misallocated payment and true overpayment, then retain evidence of the correction to the intended liability.
Identify whether the problem is credit, correction or overpayment
A payment under the correct taxpayer but wrong year may need an allocation correction. A payment under another PAN raises a different problem. An amount correctly credited against a liability may not be an overpayment at all, even if the business intended to use it elsewhere.
Similarly, withholding credits require their own analysis. Section 93 distinguishes creditable withholding from final withholding and connects the credit to the relevant payment and income year. A payer’s deduction from an invoice should not be claimed twice or treated as the recipient’s advance tax without establishing the applicable category and evidence.
For example, the same certificate may have been included in two working papers while the tax account shows only one deposit. Reconcile the underlying income, payer, certificate and deposit before deciding that the department has lost a credit.
Do not manufacture an offset
An unmatched voucher should not be inserted into a later return merely to make the account balance. Establish the applicable correction process with the competent office or payment authority and retain the acknowledgement. A request is not the same as an approved transfer, and a verbal assurance does not prove that the tax account was corrected.
If there is a genuine excess payment, section 113 provides the statutory set-off and refund framework. Finance Act 2083 extends the section 113(4) application period from two years to five years, measured from the latest of the specified events. Those events and the other conditions need to be applied to the particular claim.
The refund rule is not proof that every wrong-PAN or wrong-year transaction must be refunded. First establish ownership of the payment, allocation, existing liabilities and whether correction or refund is the proper route.
A credit balance is not interchangeable with every deposit
In Qurex Pharmaceuticals, Decision No. 10551 of 2076/05/16, the Supreme Court addressed fairness where an accepted VAT review was rejected without a reasonable chance to supply an additional deposit after reliance on a credit balance was not accepted. The judgment did not declare every credit balance legally interchangeable with a required deposit.
The same discipline helps payment reconciliation: identify the legal purpose of each amount rather than treating all money in the tax account as freely transferable. Preserve the accepted correction, revised account and reconciliation closing the difference. That final evidence is what establishes that the intended liability has actually been settled.
A part payment: who decides which tax year or source it clears?
A bank payment and its allocation answer different questions.
The precise situation covered
Rule 30 applies where a person owes tax, interest and fees for different income years or sources but does not pay the whole amount. The Department decides which income year or source the amount paid is treated as satisfying. The taxpayer cannot assume that writing a preferred description settles every competing balance.
The rule does not itself prescribe a universal sequence of oldest year first, tax before interest, or newest assessment first. An actual allocation must be identified before concluding that a particular year’s liability has disappeared. A banking receipt proves a payment; it does not alone prove which of several valid debts was cleared.
Why the remaining balance matters
For example, payment of Rs 60,000 against combined balances of Rs 100,000 leaves Rs 40,000 outstanding in total. That arithmetic does not determine which year or source retains the balance. The allocation decision matters to the continuing liability and any applicable interest. This is a firm-created illustration of Rule 30, not an IRD example.
Distinguish this situation from a wrong-PAN payment, a duplicate voucher or a refund claim. Those questions concern ownership, posting or excess payment. Rule 30 concerns an insufficient payment against multiple actual liabilities. Likewise, special auction-proceeds allocation under section 105(5) has its own statutory sequence and should not be replaced by a general assumption drawn from Rule 30.
Key points
- Rule 30 gives the Department the allocation decision when the full balance is not paid.
- There is no general oldest-year-first or principal-first formula in that rule.
Authentic Rule 30 mechanism
Where the total owing across years or sources is not fully paid, the Department determines the year or source to which the payment belongs. The rule addresses allocation of a real payment; it does not itself cancel the unpaid remainder.
Current legal position
The checked Rule 30 wording remains the authority for this limited decision. Obtain the actual allocation before applying later year-specific calculations; no automatic priority is invented.
Judgments discussed
- Inland Revenue Office, Bhaktapur v Qurex Pharmaceuticals - Decision No. 10551
Judgment: 2076/05/16 B.S. · 4-8. Finding and limits.
Sources and references
The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.