Start with the income-tax valuation rule
Section 15 of the Income Tax Act determines the allowance for trading stock through opening value, stock costs and closing value. The closing-value rule compares cost with market value and takes the lower amount. This creates a statutory valuation question; it does not authorise an unsupported reduction whenever management believes a product will be difficult to sell.
Identify the stock item, quantity, condition and valuation date. Distinguish a market-price decline from physical damage, expiry, theft and a recording error. Each explanation requires different evidence, even if the resulting accounting entry is posted to the same expense account.
Key points
- Bridge the stock count to the tax working, including recoveries, so the same loss is not deducted through two accounts.
A count difference is not a valuation report
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Suppose records show 500 units at NPR 1,000 each. Only 480 are found, including 30 damaged units. There are two issues: the unexplained absence of 20 units and the recoverable market value of 30 units that remain. Applying a percentage reduction to all 500 units answers neither question properly.
Reconcile purchases, transfers, sales, returns and consumption before concluding that stock has disappeared. For damaged goods, retain photographs, inspection findings and evidence supporting the market-value assessment. For destruction or disposal, preserve the approval, movement record, recipient details and any proceeds or insurance recovery.
Production loss is different from missing trading stock
Its practical relevance is the need to explain the process. A manufacturer may have a technically supportable conversion loss. A trader cannot adopt the same percentage merely because both businesses handle the same product. Production records, yield information and stock movements should establish the claim actually being made.
Check VAT separately before destroying goods
An income-tax valuation loss does not by itself establish entitlement to retain or adjust input VAT. Examine the applicable VAT provisions and any required procedure for damaged, lost or destroyed stock before carrying out a disposal that removes the evidence. A board approval is a useful company record, but it is not a substitute for a requirement imposed by tax law.
The final working should bridge the physical count to closing stock and then to the tax adjustment. Show recoveries separately and avoid claiming the same loss through both cost of sales and another deduction. Where evidence remains incomplete, record that limitation rather than presenting a management estimate as an established tax entitlement.
Damaged, expired or missing stock: preserve the VAT evidence before disposal
A stock write-down does not automatically preserve input VAT.
Identify the loss before removing the evidence
Section 16ख and Rule 39क provide a conditional VAT-credit route for qualifying damaged, destroyed or expired goods. First identify the item, quantity, purchase tax, event date and what remains. A board minute or accounting write-off helps explain the decision but does not replace the tax procedure. Reconcile stock counts, transfers, sales and production before describing a difference as destruction. Preserve photographs, incident reports, inspection findings and relevant purchase records as evidence, rather than treating this suggested evidence list as a prescribed form.
Unexplained missing goods present another risk. Under Rule 40(1), credited goods not found in taxable use, or absent when they should be in stock, can be deemed sold at market value. Actual manufacturing consumption or supported wastage requires its own explanation. Mittal Tea distinguishes production loss from unexplained trading-stock shortage; it gives no universal wastage percentage.
Meet the relevant application deadline
For fire, theft, accident, breakage, natural disaster or destructive activity, current Rule 39क(1)(क) requires application to the tax officer within thirty days of the event. Expired goods use a different calendar: Shrawan-Ashoj expiries by Kartik 25; Kartik-Poush by Magh 25; Magh-Chaitra by Baisakh 25; and Baisakh-Ashadh by Shrawan 25. Do not substitute the incident-loss thirty-day rule for every expiry.
Under Rule 39क(2), the officer may allow credit after examining and establishing the loss or expiry. The application is not automatic approval. Document any inspection, disposal and quantities remaining so the same goods cannot be presented later as ordinary saleable stock. A destruction decision should preserve the evidence needed to assess the claim.
Key points
- Incident loss, expired goods and manufacturing wastage need different evidence.
- Keep application, insurance and any salvage sale separately traceable.
Separate insurance and salvage
The proviso for insured goods permits the taxpayer’s own credit to the extent of compensation received. Keep the claim, insurer’s determination, actual receipt and corresponding loss/credit calculation together. This preserves eligible treatment of the loss; it is not a second claim for input VAT already taken. A proposed insurance claim is not the same evidence as compensation received.
If damaged goods or scrap are actually sold or transferred, examine that supply separately under the current classification, value and invoice rules. Loss approval does not itself exempt a salvage sale. Reconcile its quantity and proceeds with destruction records and any insurer’s salvage arrangement. Keep this VAT working separate from the article’s income-tax stock-valuation and recovery calculations.
Directive clause 7.16 - unnumbered flood illustration
The Directive treats stock damaged by flood as loss comparable to accident and directs the taxpayer to Rule 39क for credit and stock treatment. It supplies no taxpayer name, amount, year or fixed loss percentage. Current express natural-disaster amendments and the applicable evidence and procedure must also be read.
Current legal position
The Rule expressly added natural disaster from 2083/02/15; the Act’s express addition commenced 2083/03/30. Keep these distinct dates and the older flood guidance in view, rather than assuming every earlier loss has the same outcome.
Rule 39क(1)(क): loss caused by natural disaster
Before: The listed causes included fire, theft, accident, breakage and destructive activities; natural disaster was not separately stated in that list.
Change: Rule 5 inserts natural disaster after breakage.
Instrument: VAT (Twenty-eighth Amendment) Rules 2083, Rule 5, PDF 2.
Effective date: Immediate under Rule 1(2), PDF 2; Gazette 2083/02/15.
Practical effect: Use the loss-credit application/evidence procedure, including the 30-day period for these causes and the separate insurance-compensation rule. This amendment does not make every damaged item automatically creditable.
Section 16ख: natural-disaster loss
Before: The Act through Finance 2082 referred to fire, theft, accident, breakage, destructive activity and goods with expired usability, without expressly naming natural disaster.
Change: Natural disaster is expressly added after breakage.
Instrument: Finance Act 2083 section 55(4), PDF/printed page 24.
Effective date: Immediate under section 1(2), PDF page 2; Gazette 2083/03/30.
Practical effect: The Act and the earlier Rules 28 change should be read together, with the prescribed loss-credit conditions. This is separate from private diversion or ordinary changed use. Directive clause 7.16 already treated flood damage as accident; the express additions do not establish that all earlier flood claims were disallowed.
Mittal Tea Industries v Inland Revenue Department
Court: Supreme Court, Division Bench
Citation: NKP 8173; criminal appeal 3726/2062
Decision date: 2065/12/10
Issue: Production wastage versus missing trading stock.
Holding: Paragraphs 7-10 distinguish production wastage. Paragraph 11 partly reverses the shortage assessment, while affirming the separate defective-invoice result.
Relevance: Explain actual consumption and stock movement.
Limits: Historical periods 2055-2057; no universal percentage. Tribunal result reported through Supreme Court, not separate fulltext. No exhaustive citator clearance.
Judgments discussed
- Mittal Tea Industries Pvt. Ltd. v VAT Department - Decision No. 8173
Judgment: 2065/12/10 B.S. · 5, 7-11. Finding and limits.
Sources and references
The cited version and the law applicable to the transaction period matter. Older judgments are discussed for their stated findings; later amendments and different facts may change the result. This article is general information.