Commercial Law

An Online Order Is Disputed: E-Commerce Duties and the Transaction Evidence

An online seller changes its product page after a customer complains. The invoice still shows the price, but neither side can readily establish the delivery promise or return terms displayed when the order was placed. For an electronic-commerce dispute, preserving the original transaction terms can matter as much as keeping the payment receipt.

On this pageKeep the contract tied to the orderSeparate the seller, platform and delivery rolesA return policy must be read with the ActPreserve a usable transaction historyLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Keep the contract tied to the order

Section 7 of the Electronic Commerce Act, 2081 recognises electronic contracts between the relevant trading parties and the obligations they create. It also requires necessary terms concerning supply, cancellation, return, exchange, warranty or guarantee and refund. A generic website policy is of limited help if the seller cannot establish which version applied to the disputed purchase.

The Act is the enacted 2081 law, authenticated on 2081/12/03, corresponding to 2025. Earlier drafts and the 2080 Bill should not be quoted as though they were its final provisions. This distinction matters because draft language may differ from the enacted text.

Key points

  • Preserve the product description and terms that applied to the particular online order, including delivery and returns.
  • Distinguish seller, platform and delivery responsibilities, and read the stated return policy with the applicable e-commerce law.

Separate the seller, platform and delivery roles

A marketplace transaction can involve a buyer, intermediary, separate seller and delivery provider. The customer-facing page should not leave the legal parties unclear. Section 16(a) requires the seller's written or electronic contract with the intermediary before supplying goods or services through its platform. The seller-platform agreement should therefore be retained alongside the relevant trading records.

For example, a platform promises delivery in two days while its supplier agreement permits dispatch after five. The mismatch is a foreseeable dispute, even if the platform later blames the supplier. Identify which promise the buyer received, who accepted it and how the parties allocated responsibility between themselves. Internal allocation does not necessarily dispose of statutory obligations towards the buyer.

A return policy must be read with the Act

Section 6 requires product or service disclosures, including price, delivery, warranty and relevant return or cancellation details. Section 10 addresses goods or services not corresponding to the disclosed description, with its stated conditions. It should not be paraphrased as either an unrestricted change-of-mind right or permission for sellers to reject every return under a “no refunds” policy.

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose a buyer orders one specification but receives another. Preserve the listing, accepted order, delivered item and complaint before arguing about whether the buyer simply changed their mind. The condition of the returned goods and the statutory requirements may be relevant. Analyse the actual reason for return rather than rely on the label applied by one side.

Preserve a usable transaction history

Retain the product-page version, order and acceptance, applicable terms, payment and invoice, dispatch and delivery evidence, and complaint or refund correspondence. The Act's intermediary obligations include retaining transaction records for the period determined by relevant tax law according to their nature. There is no single retention period safely inferred for every record from this article.

Make the records retrievable by order number and protect them from silent alteration. This is a practical way to support the legal enquiry, not a claim that a software log proves every disputed fact. If identity, assent or integrity is challenged, those questions need their own evidence under the applicable law.

Sources and references

This article provides general information. Apply the law in force for the relevant period to the actual facts.