Commercial Law

A Business Lease Ends Before the Investment Is Recovered: Term, Use and Improvement Clauses

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

A business may spend heavily fitting out rented premises before discovering that the agreement does not clearly permit its intended use. Disputes then arise over alterations, shared access, early departure or the return of a deposit. These issues are easier to resolve before possession and expenditure begin.

On this pageClassify the property and purpose correctlyWrite the permitted use preciselyDeal with costs and responsibilities before occupationConsider the end while negotiating the beginningLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Classify the property and purpose correctly

The Civil Code contains house-rent provisions as well as provisions governing contracts of lease. A rented shop floor, land on which the tenant will build, and machinery leased with a building should not automatically be treated as identical transactions. The applicable provisions and any required formalities need to be identified for the arrangement actually proposed.

Section 385's general house-rent period includes a specific exception for commercial purposes, where the agreement determines the period. It is therefore misleading to tell every business that its premises agreement can never exceed five years. Longer or differently structured property arrangements still require examination of the relevant lease, registration and other legal requirements.

Key points

  • Agree the permitted use, alterations, access and cost responsibilities before investing in rented premises.
  • Address expiry and early exit alongside occupation, including improvements and deposit treatment, rather than assuming the fitting-out cost will be recovered.

Write the permitted use precisely

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose a tenant intends to operate a restaurant, install extraction equipment and use a roof area. An agreement merely saying “office use” does not explain the landlord's permission for those activities or areas. Record the actual premises, access, common facilities, permitted business and consent process for material changes.

The owner's consent does not itself establish compliance with building, product or sector regulations. The business should identify those separate requirements before relying on a promise that the premises are “suitable”. Section 384 also makes the agreed standards relevant for specified non-residential uses. A site inspection and condition record help the parties document what is being provided.

Deal with costs and responsibilities before occupation

Section 386 identifies matters for the rental agreement, including purpose, term, rent, payment, utilities, tax, insurance, departure and subletting. It also contains formal requirements and a limited exception to writing for lower monthly rents. A substantial commercial arrangement is best recorded clearly even where a particular exception might otherwise apply.

Explain who pays for structural work, routine maintenance and reinstatement at the end. If the tenant pays a deposit, state what it secures, when deductions may be made and how the balance will be returned. These are practical drafting measures; an agreed allocation must still be tested against applicable law.

Consider the end while negotiating the beginning

A tenant installing expensive fixtures should settle whether they may be removed, must be removed or may remain for an agreed payment. Record who owns additions and how the premises will be handed back. Avoid assuming that an oral promise about recovering fit-out costs will be easy to establish years later.

If the owner seeks possession early, separate the agreed end date, any valid break provision, the alleged breach and the relevant notice. The amount spent on improvements does not itself establish a right to remain or an automatic right to recover every rupee. Equally, a request to leave is not proof that the contract has lawfully ended. Preserve the expenditure approvals and analyse the actual termination and remedy provisions before signing a settlement.

Renewal should be distinguished from an expectation that the landlord will agree. Address notice, the renewal mechanism and rent adjustment if the parties intend them to be binding. For an immovable-property lease, section 620 raises writing and registration questions that require separate attention to the legal structure and duration. Preserve the signed agreement, authority, condition photographs, payment receipts and amendment record. They should tell one consistent story about the premises and rights the business acquired.

Tenant-funded fit-outs: repairs, rent deductions and a later handover

Agree who authorises, pays for and owns each part of the work.

Separate repairs from structural changes

A shop or office tenant may pay for repairs, partitions, wiring or other fit-out work. Start with the lease and written approvals. Identify the contractor’s customer, the work performed, who bears its cost and what may be removed at the end. A fixed-asset ledger description cannot establish all these facts. Keep the contractor’s supply, the rent account and any later handover separately identifiable.

Civil Code section 394 makes necessary repairs the tenant’s responsibility unless the agreement states otherwise. Where the landlord must repair, the tenant gives timely written notice; if the landlord still fails, the tenant may repair and deduct the billed amount from rent. Unless a separate agreement covers this, subsection (5) requires the cost estimate and written information to the landlord five days before the repair. This civil mechanism is not a VAT credit note.

Record consent and the financial settlement

Under section 396, unless the agreement provides otherwise, the tenant cannot demolish, remove, damage, extend or otherwise alter the house structure without the landlord’s written consent. Unauthorised work causing loss can give rise to compensation. Consent does not itself establish who owns every installed item, whether the landlord purchased a service or whether a payment is VAT consideration. Record those terms and the actual transaction.

Keep separate amounts for rent, the contractor’s bill, an agreed reimbursement, a deduction and any compensation. Match each to its document and counterparty. If an earlier supply’s value genuinely changes, test Rule 20 and the appropriate invoice-linked adjustment. Merely settling two obligations against each other does not prove that the construction supply disappeared or that VAT should be reversed.

Key points

  • A deduction from rent does not itself cancel a contractor’s VAT invoice.
  • Analyse any later transfer separately from the original construction purchase.

Review input credit and the eventual exit

The registered person claiming input VAT must establish the purchase, prescribed evidence and use in its taxable activity under section 17. Payment or capitalisation alone is insufficient. Mixed taxable and exempt use requires its own analysis. A lease ending also does not automatically reverse every input credit: section 17(4) has conditions concerning previously credited goods or services ceasing taxable use before the prescribed utility period. Where those conditions are met, section 17(4) treats the goods or services as sold at current market value and provides for tax recovery as prescribed. No universal fit-out period is assumed.

At exit, list assets removed, sold, left in place or otherwise dealt with, and record the landlord’s acceptance and any consideration. Analyse the actual supply and applicable exemption wording. Neither a building label nor a zero cash payment alone establishes that every transferred fit-out is exempt or taxable. This resource supplies the contractual and evidence framework; a particular vesting, reimbursement or handover still needs its own VAT determination.

C.M. & Associates illustration - a repair deducted from rent

Assume monthly rent is Rs. 40,000 and an agreed, properly documented repair deduction is Rs. 10,000. The remaining rent payment is Rs. 30,000. Retain the repair approval, contractor’s invoice and rent reconciliation. This subtraction determines neither the VAT in the repair bill nor the tenant’s credit entitlement, and creates no automatic VAT reversal.

Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.

Current legal position

The specific civil repair and consent rules do not settle all tax consequences of landlord handover. No directly fitting primary VAT judgment or special tenant-fit-out regime was authenticated. The narrower framework here leaves those outcome questions open.

Sources and references

This article provides general information. Apply the law in force for the relevant period to the actual facts.