Company Law

A lost share certificate during transfer: replacement and ownership

A seller agrees to transfer shares and then discovers that the paper certificate is missing. The buyer asks the company to issue a replacement directly in the buyer’s name. That request combines two different processes: replacing evidence of an existing holding and registering a change in ownership.

On this pageBegin with the registered holdingReplacement follows inquiryA transfer must stand on its own documentationListed and dematerialised holdings need the appropriate routeLegal sourcesTax and law analysis

Begin with the registered holding

Section 33(3) of the Companies Act 2063 requires a shareholder to inform the company’s registered office as soon as the shareholder learns that a certificate has been lost or destroyed. The notice should identify the holder, shares and certificate details available, and explain when and how the loss became known.

The company should compare the request with its share register, certificate records and any transfer or security notice already received. A missing certificate does not justify ignoring an existing pledge, competing claim or inconsistency in the register.

Key points

  • Replacing a lost certificate confirms evidence of an existing holding; registering a transfer changes ownership and needs its own documents.
  • Check the company’s registered holding and use the appropriate route for physical, listed or dematerialised shares.

Replacement follows inquiry

Under section 33(4), the company makes the necessary inquiries. If it finds the request reasonable, it issues another certificate on payment of the fee prescribed in its articles and records the replacement in the shareholder register.

That section does not establish a universal checklist requiring every shareholder to obtain a police report or publish a newspaper notice. Those documents may be relevant under a lawful company or securities/depository process, or because particular facts require further evidence. Their legal basis should be identified rather than presented as requirements automatically imposed by section 33.

A transfer must stand on its own documentation

Illustration applying the source rule

CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.

Suppose the register still records the seller, but the buyer provides a purchase agreement and payment receipt. Those documents may support the buyer’s contractual position. They do not make the replacement process a shortcut around applicable transfer documents, restrictions, approvals or registration.

The company should record whether it is issuing replacement evidence for the existing registered holder or completing a separately established transfer. The final certificate and register should reflect the lawful result of those processes, not simply the person who delivers the application first.

If the seller and buyer disagree about whether payment was complete or transfer conditions were met, a replacement certificate should not be treated as the company’s determination of that dispute. Preserve both claims and identify the competent process for resolving them.

Listed and dematerialised holdings need the appropriate route

Section 33(5) recognises alternative evidence where a listed company uses an authorised securities registrar or depository arrangement. A paper-certificate procedure may therefore be the wrong route for a dematerialised holding. Confirm the issuer, registrar and depository records before requiring someone to recreate a document the system no longer uses.

Section 33(6) treats the relevant company-issued certificate as preliminary evidence of ownership. It should not be described as conclusive evidence that overrides every contrary register entry or court order.

The completed file should show the loss notice, inquiries, decision, fee basis, new certificate reference and register notation. Keep transfer papers separately linked so a future reader can distinguish replacement from the transaction that changed ownership.

Sources and references

This article provides general information. Apply the law in force for the relevant period to the actual facts.