The invoice restriction has a specific boundary
Section 21(1)(घ2) of the Income Tax Act restricts deduction of expenses against invoices exceeding NPR 2,000 that do not state a PAN. “Exceeding” matters: the provision should not be rewritten as NPR 2,000 or more. Equally, an amount below that threshold does not become automatically deductible if the expense is personal, unrelated to earning income or otherwise restricted.
The general business-expense conditions still apply. The business must establish who incurred the expense, the income-earning purpose and the correct tax treatment. Capital expenditure, for example, requires the appropriate treatment rather than becoming an ordinary expense because a PAN appears on the invoice.
Key points
- Separate proof that money was spent from the statutory conditions for deducting it, including supplier status and payment method.
- Apply any direct-purchase exception within its actual scope. A bank transfer cannot replace every invoice requirement.
Read the direct-purchase exception narrowly
The proviso addresses direct purchases of agricultural, forest, livestock and other household goods from natural persons who do not carry on business, even where the seller has not obtained PAN. This is an identifiable statutory exception; it is not a general permission to accept PAN-less bills from regular commercial suppliers.
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Consider a restaurant buying produce directly from a qualifying nonbusiness grower and buying packaged supplies from a trader. The two files should not be treated alike merely because both suppliers accept cash. Identify the seller, what was bought, quantities, date, payment and the facts supporting any exception. A label written by the purchaser stating “agricultural purchase” is not a substitute for those facts.
A PAN invoice and a VAT invoice answer different questions
PAN identification helps address the income-tax invoice condition. Input VAT requires a separate entitlement under the VAT Act and Rules. An ordinary PAN bill should not be used to claim VAT that the supplier was not entitled to charge or that is not supported by the prescribed tax invoice.
Likewise, withholding tax from a payment does not necessarily cure a missing invoice requirement. The payer may have a withholding obligation while still needing to establish the deduction. Those are different statutory questions and should have separate lines in the review working.
The payment method now deserves particular attention
Finance Act 2083 changes section 21(2): the cash-payment restriction now refers to a payment exceeding NPR 25,000 by any person, subject to the statutory exceptions. It replaces the earlier wording tied to annual turnover exceeding NPR 2 million and a NPR 50,000 payment threshold.
That change means an older checklist may reach the wrong result even when the PAN invoice is adequate. Review the applicable income year and the exact banking exception, if any. Do not turn a deduction restriction into an unsupported statement that every cash transaction is criminal or legally void.
Prepare the file before filing the return
List material supplier-document gaps and resolve them with the actual supplier. Retain the original evidence and any lawful corrected document; never create a replacement invoice in the supplier’s name without authority. Where an exception is claimed, state the provision and the facts establishing it.
The final tax reconciliation should distinguish deductible expenses, capital items and disallowances, with reasons. This approach produces a defensible conclusion about the particular payment rather than a misleading rule that every purchase is either safe because money left the bank or disallowed because its paperwork looks unusual.
Sources and references
Income Tax Act, 2058, sections 13 and 21(1)(घ2), including the proviso:
VAT Act, 2052, sections 14, 15 and 17 for the separate VAT-invoice and credit questions:
This article provides general information. Apply the law in force for the relevant period to the actual facts.