Start with the transaction rather than the percentage
Section 89 of the Income Tax Act governs specified contract payments by resident persons. Its ordinary rule applies to a payment exceeding NPR 50,000 and provides for 1.5% withholding, subject to the section’s exclusions and special rules. For the threshold, subsection (2) requires relevant payments under the same contract during the preceding ten days to be combined, including specified associated-person payments.
That does not make 1.5% the answer to every supplier payment. Section 89(4) excludes, among other matters, payments governed by sections 87, 88 or 88A. The recipient’s residence and the character of the arrangement also matter. A service-fee payment cannot simply be classified as a construction payment because the invoice says “contract.”
Key points
- Distinguish commercial retention, income-tax withholding, customer-deposited VAT and security before analysing payment timing.
- Trace the contract and release history under the provisions applicable to the period, including relevant amendments, rather than applying an old rate table to the net receipt.
Retention requires a separate timing analysis
Section 2(ह) defines payment more broadly than a bank transfer. It includes specified transfers of money, property or liabilities, creation of property belonging to another person, and another person bearing a liability. A noncash settlement therefore needs examination; absence of cash alone does not settle the withholding question.
A retention normally secures satisfactory performance or the correction of defects. Its release conditions may differ from the conditions for earning the underlying contract price. The certified amount, the legal payment or settlement, the receivable recorded and the bank receipt can therefore be different figures.
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Consider a certified bill of NPR 1 million before VAT, with NPR 50,000 retained until the defects period ends. A working that calculates tax only on the cash received has assumed the answer before examining the contract. Equally, applying withholding to every amount described as retained without identifying the relevant payment event may be wrong. Read the certification, settlement terms, deduction certificate and release conditions together before deciding the withholding base and timing.
A genuine refundable security deposit needs another analysis. Ask whether it remains the depositor’s money, whether it is applied against the price, and what happens on breach or completion. Calling part of the contract price a deposit does not change its substance.
Government VAT deposits are a different obligation
Historical VAT deposit passage - Rule 6ग was repealed from 2083/02/15; the former 30% figures below are not a current deduction instruction. VAT Rule 6C requires covered government and government-owned payers to deposit 30% of the VAT component in the supplier’s name under the specified contract-payment arrangement. This is separate from income-tax withholding and performance retention. The supplier needs the deposit information to reconcile the credit against VAT payable.
For example, a payment advice should distinguish the contract value, VAT, income-tax TDS, VAT deposited and commercial retention. A single unexplained “tax and retention” line prevents a reliable reconciliation and can leave both tax credits and receivables misstated.
Keep a release file as well as a payment file
Retain the signed contract, certified bills, retention clauses, payment advice, tax certificates, VAT deposit vouchers and subsequent release records. Reconcile each bill through to the final settlement. Do not claim a withholding credit merely because a customer deducted cash; obtain evidence of the tax treatment and allocation.
The applicable law must also match the period. Finance Act 2083 removes the former section 89(3A) provision concerning consumer-committee payments. An old rate table containing that provision is not a complete current answer. The defensible conclusion comes from the operative provision and the payment facts, supported by a working that another reader can follow.
Retention and tax deductions: reconcile the VAT supply separately
Commercial retention, income-tax withholding and a customer’s VAT deposit are different items.
Identify what the deduction actually represents
Read the contract, certification, invoice and payment advice together. Identify the agreed supply value, VAT, income-tax withholding, performance retention and any separately held security. Do not combine them into one unexplained deduction. For VAT, section 12 concerns the value of the supply, while section 6 concerns its time. Neither question is settled merely by the cash finally received. The separate income-tax passages address that tax’s own rules.
A retention securing defects or completion is not automatically a reduction in the agreed supply price. Conversely, a certified or recorded amount does not by itself establish every VAT event without examining what the contract and actual supply require. Keep the disputed or conditional amount identifiable. A genuine later price change requires its own evidence and the applicable Rule 20 note process; do not manufacture a price discount from a payment deduction.
Apply the actual VAT timing and deposit provisions
Section 6(2) ordinarily selects the earliest applicable invoice, goods receipt, service performance or consideration event. Section 6(3) has special rules, including contractual instalments at the earlier of payment and the contractual due date. Test the actual provision rather than treating unpaid retention as an automatic deferral of all VAT. A later release should be linked to what was already invoiced and reported so the same supply is not taxed twice.
Section 12(8) excludes a deposit for goods or services from taxable value until the supplier adjusts it as consideration in the prescribed manner. Establish that it is genuinely such a deposit, its return and application terms, and the actual adjustment. The words retention, security and advance are not interchangeable legal conclusions. The customer-advance guide explains the common distinction without deciding every cancellation or forfeiture.
Key points
- A reduced bank receipt does not alone determine output VAT or input credit.
- The former government-contract VAT-deposit rule has been repealed.
Use the correct period for government-contract deposits
Rule 6ग formerly required specified government or government-owned payers to deposit 30% of VAT under qualifying contracts. The 28th Amendment repealed that rule from 2083/02/15. Finance 2083 later deleted the separate section 25ग1 from 2083/03/30. Do not present either former route as a current general customer-deposit obligation. Historical payments, balances and pending claims still require their own dates and documents; repeal alone does not decide each balance.
For a historical deposit, trace the payer’s voucher, supplier identity, invoice and actual amount posted. A customer’s unexplained deduction does not prove that VAT was deposited or that a credit is available. Reconcile VAT separately from income-tax withholding evidence and commercial retention; keep subsequent release or settlement records with the original bill. The government-contract transition guide addresses the former route in more detail.
C.M. & Associates illustration: one bill, distinct balances
Assume a Rs. 1000000 before-VAT bill and Rs. 50,000 performance retention. If the actual supply is ordinary taxable at 13%, VAT is Rs. 130,000. The retained Rs. 50,000 is not automatically a Rs. 50,000 price reduction or a VAT payment. Establish each legal event and deduction separately; this illustration does not decide the income-tax withholding amount.
Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.
Current legal position
Preserve a reconciliation that another reader can follow from the original supply through payment and final release. Use the law applicable to each period and the separate tax-credit evidence.
Former government-contract VAT deposit and refund route
Before: Rule 6ग required the specified payer’s 30% VAT deposit; section 25ग1 provided supplier adjustment and the stated excess-balance refund route.
Change: Rule 6ग is repealed; section 25ग1 is separately deleted later. These are distinct instruments and commencement dates.
Instrument: 28th Amendment Rules 2083 rule 8, PDF 3; Finance Act 2083 section 55(7), PDF 25.
Effective date: Rule repeal immediately under rule 1(2), 2083/02/15; Act deletion immediately under section 1(2), 2083/03/30.
Practical effect: Do not apply the old mechanism as a current blanket deduction. Historical balances require period-specific examination, not an automatic write-off or refund.
Sources and references
This article provides general information. Apply the law in force for the relevant period to the actual facts.