Who owns the entity underneath the holding companies?
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
Direct shareholding and underlying ownership are different measurements.
Follow the interest through each layer
Section 2(ra) identifies ownership created by interests held directly or through one or more interposed entities by a natural person, or an entity in which no natural person has an interest. The definition also attributes ownership of an entity’s property proportionately to its underlying owners. The starting document may be the immediate shareholder register, but the statutory inquiry can continue above it.
An interest is not confined to a certificate labelled ordinary shares: section 2(ma) includes rights, including contingent rights, to income or capital. Establish what the relevant rights represent before using a nominal share percentage as the complete answer. Different legal tests may then use the resulting ownership information for associated-person transfers, ownership changes or treaty eligibility.
Do not confuse the calculation with its consequence
The percentage tracing does not itself impose a universal tax. Section 45,57 or 73 must supply its own operative conditions, thresholds and exceptions. Equally, a beneficial-ownership disclosure threshold under another law should not replace the Income Tax Act definition.
The company remains the owner of its assets for section 52 purposes. Tracing a shareholder’s proportionate underlying interest in company land does not register that shareholder as the landowner or make the company’s receipts personal receipts. The tracing rule and separate-entity principle perform different functions.
In a multilevel chain, stopping at a convenient holding company can conceal the actual statutory owner. Trace every relevant branch; combine a person’s interests arising through different branches without counting the same interest twice. If the source example ends at intermediate companies, further ownership facts may still be needed for a complete application.
Key points
- Multiply interests along each chain, then trace to the statutory end owner.
- An underlying interest in company property does not give the shareholder legal title to that property.
Directive 13.3.1: the original 40% branch
Shital Investment holds 40% of Himal Byapar. Sharmili Pvt. Ltd. holds 80% of Shital and Diwakar Pvt. Ltd. 20%. The Directive attributes indirect interests of 32% (80% x 40%) and 8% (20% x 40%) through that branch. They total Shital’s 40%, not 100% of Himal. The example gives no income year and does not provide every ultimate-owner fact.
Current legal position
The Ncell judgment illustrates why an offshore intermediary does not end the inquiry. Apply its historical holding within its facts and test the current operative provision separately.
Dwarikanath Dhungel and others v Large Taxpayer Office and others
Court: Supreme Court, extended full bench
Citation: Decision 10163;074-WO-0475; paragraphs 21-23
Decision date: 2075/10/23
Issue: Indirect ownership through foreign holding companies
Holding: The Court looked through the interposed structure in the Ncell transaction and applied underlying-ownership/disposal provisions.
Relevance: A locally unchanged shareholder register does not end the underlying-ownership inquiry.
Limits: Historical transaction-specific section 57 decision; not a ruling that every offshore sale is taxable. Later assessment litigation and current exceptions require separate analysis.