When the payer fails to withhold: who must pay and what can be recovered?
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
Failure to deduct tax can leave both payer and recipient responsible for the tax.
Joint responsibility has a defined trigger
Section 90(5) makes the withholder and the person whose payment should have suffered withholding jointly and severally responsible in its stated circumstances. These include failure to withhold under sections 87, 88, 88A or 89 and failure to deposit the amount treated as withheld under section 90(3) within the section 90(4) deadline. A contract describing the payment as “tax free” does not remove the statutory duty.
This liability must be distinguished from a case where tax was actually deducted from the recipient. Under section 90(6), tax deducted and deposited with the Department is treated as payment to the recipient when that recipient claims the withheld part of the payment. The payer should therefore identify whether tax was deducted, deemed deducted or paid later from its own funds.
Recovery is of the undeducted tax
Section 90(7) allows the withholder to recover from the recipient an amount equivalent to tax which the withholder deposited without first deducting it. It does not say that every consequence of the payer’s default becomes a debt owed by the recipient. The Directive expressly distinguishes the tax from interest and fees in its bank-director example.
The recipient’s position also depends on the payment’s classification. A creditable withholding amount and a final withholding amount have different income-tax consequences. Recovery between the parties should not be confused with a second entitlement to an income-tax credit.
Key points
- A payer who later pays the undeducted tax may recover the equivalent tax from the recipient. This does not transfer the payer’s interest or fees.
An order requires an opportunity to answer
Under section 90(8), the Department may order payment where the required withholding return or tax was not submitted, or the section 90(5) circumstances exist. The order can cover unpaid or short-paid tax, section 119 interest and, where tax was not withheld from a payment requiring withholding, the section 120 fee. Before ordering payment, it must give written reasons and fifteen days to submit evidence in answer.
The useful response is therefore specific: identify the payment, applicable withholding provision, actual deduction and deposit, and any part of the proposed computation that is wrong. The opportunity to answer does not itself cancel a valid withholding debt.
Directive example 16.5.7 - director’s meeting allowance
Pran Pakheru receives Rs 5,000 as a director’s meeting allowance from Nepal Bank Limited without deduction. The bank later deposits Rs 750, calculated at the example’s 15% rate. The Directive allows the bank to recover that Rs 750 from the director. It expressly says that any interest and fees paid by the bank cannot be claimed from him under this recovery explanation.
Current legal position
The explanation applies section 90(5)-(8) as checked in the retained Act. The example is the Directive’s illustration; whether a particular payment is final or creditable must be decided under the applicable withholding provisions.