When a debt meets its own liability: disposal by merger of rights

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

Section 47 concerns extinguished or merged rights and obligations.

Identify the item that disappears

The rule applies when acquiring an asset or assuming a liability causes another asset already owned or liability already borne to cease or merge. For example, a person’s debt claim and corresponding obligation may meet in the same arrangement. Determine which existing item is extinguished and which acquisition or assumption caused it; netting two accounting balances is not the whole statutory test.

Section 47 also addresses specified acquisition/sale, acquisition of leased property and transfer of a liability guaranteed by the transferee, subject to its principal rule. The legal rights and burdens therefore matter alongside the arithmetic.

Carry the prescribed tax amounts through the merger

Where the extinguished item has net outgoings, the Act starts with those outgoings as deemed disposal receipts and carries the corresponding amount into the acquired asset/liability’s outgoings. Where the counterpart is a liability, the stated cap refers to the amount received for that liability.

For an extinguished liability with net incomings, the starting deemed settlement expenditure is those net incomings. The acquired item receives the corresponding incoming amount; where the counterpart is an asset, the statutory cap is its acquisition expenditure. These paired rules prevent a free choice of market value or a fresh cost merely because rights have merged.

The result depends on tax incomings/outgoings and the relevant cap, not just face value. A residual payable after mutual claims are offset is not necessarily a disposal profit. Corporate-merger relief formerly in 47 A is a separate provision; Finance 2083 deletes 47 A, while the distinct 47 mechanism remains.

Key points

  • It is different from a corporate merger.
  • The remaining net balance is not automatically taxable gain.

Directive 22.14.1: source figures and label

The original undated example gives Khop a Rs 7,000,000 bill payable and Rs 6,000,000 bill receivable after the stated endorsements. Its table labels the Rs 1,000,000 difference an 'asset'. On the stated payable/receivable directions, independent arithmetic instead leaves a Rs 1,000,000 net payable. Preserve that label discrepancy; the difference does not establish Rs 1,000,000 taxable gain or a new asset cost.

Source: Income Tax Directives2066,Fifth Amendment2081

Current legal position

Apply 47’s paired amounts and caps to the actual rights extinguished. The source table’s label should not reverse a liability into an asset in the taxpayer’s computation.

Corporate-merger relief, section 47 A

Before: The retained Act and Directive separately contain 47 A relief for qualifying same-nature banking/financial/insurance mergers, with conditions and historical deadlines.

Change: Finance 2083 deletes 47 A. It does not delete 47’s separate rule for merger/extinguishment of an asset or liability.

Instrument: Finance 2083,57(10), PDF 206.

Effective date: 2083 Shrawan 1 under 1(2), PDF 2.

Practical effect: Do not use the adjacent old corporate-merger chapter as current authority for this rights-merger rule or as an open current merger concession. Historical saving/transitional questions remain transaction-specific.

Sources and references