Transfer pricing methods and ranges: worked examples
Compare CUP, resale-price, cost-plus, TNMM and profit-split methods, then apply the Directive’s arm’s-length range rules. The original examples distinguish the benchmark from the adjustment and preserve their stated assumptions.
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
Comparable uncontrolled price (CUP)
The comparable uncontrolled price method tests a related-party price against a comparable independent transaction. First put both prices on the same footing; a cheaper invoice excluding freight is not yet a comparable delivered price.
When the comparison can work
The specialist Directive allows internal comparables, involving the taxpayer and an independent party, and external comparables between independent parties. The relevant transaction must have no difference materially affecting price, or the difference must permit a reliable adjustment. A price list for broadly similar goods does not establish those conditions.
Identify the actual product or service, its quality, delivery obligations, volume discounts, geographical market, credit period and allocation of risk. These features can explain why independent parties pay different prices. An adjustment must connect the identified difference to the amount used in the comparison.
The Directive distinguishes adjustable differences from materially different brands, trademarks or fundamentally different goods that prevent a dependable comparison. Removing a guessed brand premium cannot turn an unsuitable product into a valid comparable. Where such differences cannot be reliably resolved, reconsider the selected method rather than forcing a price match.
What the result changes
Compare the related-party transaction with the adjusted independent price. For an excessive purchase price, the example identifies the price adjustment. Whether the affected amount is a current expense, inventory cost or depreciable asset cost remains a separate income-tax classification question. Section 33 permits allocations reflecting arm’s-length taxable income or tax; a machine-price difference is not automatically an immediate deduction adjustment.
Key points
Apply the current relationship test and any separately applicable statutory route before relying on the ordinary method. Neither this example nor its Rs 100,000 difference creates a general tolerance or a safe harbour.
Original Directive example 5.1.1 - freight and insurance
Manakamana Pvt. Ltd. buys a packing machine from affiliate Alaska Ltd. for Rs 2,000,000 including freight and insurance. Independent Vindhyabasini Pvt. Ltd. buys the same type of machine from unrelated Pennsylvania Ltd. for Rs 1,800,000 excluding those charges, and incurs Rs 100,000 freight and insurance.
The comparable delivered price is Rs 1,800,000 + Rs 100,000 = Rs 1,900,000. Against Manakamana’s Rs 2,000,000 price, the source identifies a Rs 100,000 transfer-pricing adjustment. These are the Directive’s undated hypothetical facts, not a current machine quotation.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text
Section 33(3) and the specialist Directive
Before: Section 33 through Finance Act 2080 contained subsections (1)-(2), without the later express provision that valuation methods are as prescribed by the Department.
Change: Finance Act 2081 adds subsection (3). The specialist Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 prescribe methods and state their own application from income year 2081/82.
Instrument: Finance Act 2081, section 36(5), PDF 243; Transfer Pricing Directives, section 1.4, PDF 5.
Effective date: The statutory addition commences on 2081 Shrawan 1 under Finance Act 2081, section 1(2), PDF 2. Directive section 1.4 separately states income year 2081/82.
Practical effect: Apply the selected method and comparability conditions rather than treating a group price or an example margin as conclusive. The later English translation publication date is not the method commencement date.
Section 33 heading
Before: The heading used मूल्य हस्तान्तरण.
Change: Finance Act 2082 replaces that expression in the heading with हस्तान्तरण मूल्य.
Instrument: Finance Act 2082, section 37(6), PDF 170.
Effective date: 2082 Shrawan 1 under section 1(2), PDF 1.
Practical effect: This particular amendment changes the heading terminology, not the example benchmark or the computation of this method.
TP-specific association and separate statutory routes
Before: The retained Act through Finance Act 2082 had section 33, without the new sections 33A and 33B or the new section 2(कन)(4) TP-specific association limbs.
Change: Finance Act 2083 adds those association limbs and separate sections 33A and 33B on specified safe-harbour and advance-pricing arrangements.
Instrument: Finance Act 2083, section 57(1)(ख), PDF 200 and section 57(9), PDF 203-206.
Effective date: 2083 Shrawan 1 under section 1(2), PDF 2.
Practical effect: Recheck whether parties fall within the applicable relationship test and whether a separate statutory route actually applies. The ordinary Directive method and its example percentages do not themselves establish eligibility for that route.
Resale-price transfer pricing: work back from an independent selling price
The resale-price method starts with what a distributor charges an independent customer. Deduct a comparable gross profit and relevant additional purchasing expenses to estimate the arm’s-length purchase price from its related supplier. Gross margin and net profit are different measures.
Choose a genuinely comparable distributor
The tested party’s independent resale price supplies the starting point. The gross-profit percentage comes from comparable uncontrolled activity. Check functions, assets and risks before borrowing another distributor’s margin. Similar product names do not resolve differences in marketing responsibility, distribution level, exclusive rights or commercial maturity.
A material difference affecting gross profit must be absent or reliably adjustable. Accounting classifications also matter: a cost treated as cost of goods sold by one company and operating expense by another can change reported gross margins without changing overall profit. Compare the underlying treatment before calculating a percentage.
The method is especially useful for distribution where the reseller does not substantially transform goods or add valuable intangibles. Significant processing, brand development or different risks may undermine a simple gross-margin comparison. Selecting a convenient independent selling price does not remove those comparability requirements.
Calculate the purchase benchmark
Express comparable gross profit against sales, apply that percentage to the tested resale price, and subtract the resulting gross profit. Deduct additional purchasing expenses where the Directive requires them and avoid counting an expense twice. A margin calculated on cost cannot be substituted directly for the same percentage of sales.
The result benchmarks the related purchase price. The original example below concludes that no adjustment is needed for its particular lower purchase cost; it does not grant general protection to every transaction priced below a benchmark.
Key points
This example’s 40% is an assumed comparable gross margin. It is neither a prescribed distributor margin nor the later statutory safe-harbour rate. Relationship and route eligibility require their own current tests.
Original Directive example 5.2.2 - Arun and Barun
Arun Ltd. imports a machine from its US parent for Rs 200,000 and resells it for Rs 350,000. Independent Barun Ltd. buys a comparable machine for Rs 180,000 and sells it for Rs 300,000. The source assumes equivalent machines and contractual obligations.
Barun’s gross margin is (300,000 - 180,000) / 300,000 = 40%. Arun’s benchmark purchase price is 350,000 - (350,000 × 40%) = Rs 210,000. Its actual Rs 200,000 cost is lower, so the Directive records zero adjustment in these assumed facts. No year is specified.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text
Cost-plus transfer pricing: use the right cost base and comparable markup
A group agreement to pay cost plus a percentage does not establish an arm’s-length price. The cost-plus method adds an independently supported gross markup to a comparable cost base. Both the percentage and the costs to which it applies must be tested.
What must be comparable?
The Directive uses the method for suitable related-party production or service transactions, including limited production functions and contract manufacturing, co-production or assembly carrying limited risks. First understand the producer’s functions, assets and risks. A routine assembler and an enterprise developing valuable technology do not necessarily earn the same return.
Choose uncontrolled transactions without factors materially changing the gross markup, or make reliable adjustments for relevant differences. Consistent cost classification matters. A percentage based on direct production costs alone cannot simply be applied to a different base including every operating cost. Otherwise, the same reported markup can produce different economic returns.
The comparison is a gross cost-plus analysis. It should not be confused with a transactional net-margin method merely because both calculations refer to costs. Under the latter method, the selected operating-profit indicator and its denominator require their own analysis.
From markup to the income adjustment
Apply the comparable percentage to the appropriate cost base to derive the benchmark remuneration. Compare that with the related-party invoice. A shortfall in remuneration differs from the markup amount itself: subtract actual billed revenue from benchmark revenue, rather than treating the entire benchmark profit as an adjustment.
The example assumes that the independent markup and cost base are comparable. It does not prescribe one national percentage for all software suppliers or excuse examination of a business with different functions or valuable intangibles.
Key points
The historical illustration’s agreed 15% and independent 50% are assumed facts. Neither figure establishes eligibility or the required return under Finance Act 2083’s separate statutory safe-harbour provision.
Original Directive example 5.3.2 - two different markups
Kasthamandap Pvt. Ltd. provides software development and database management to its US parent, New York Incorporation. Its cost is USD 10,000. The group’s agreed 15% markup produces USD 11,500 revenue. The example assumes that comparable independent providers add 50% to cost.
The arm’s-length price is USD 10,000 × 1.50 = USD 15,000. The adjustment is 15,000 - 11,500 = USD 3,500. These figures follow the original Nepali table. They distinguish the benchmark price from the adjustment despite displaced formula/table text in the English translation. No income year is stated.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text
TNMM transfer pricing: choose the tested party and compare the same profit ratio
The transactional net margin method compares a suitable operating-profit ratio with comparable independent transactions. Choosing the less complex tested party and a consistent denominator is essential; a group-wide profit percentage alone does not test the controlled transaction.
Choose the party whose result can be tested
Under section 4.3 of the specialist Directive, select the related party with less complex activity, considering whether comparable information exists in the same environment. If an overseas related party is selected, the necessary information about that party and its comparables must be available to the Nepal tax administration.
The party is selected for the particular transaction. A company can be the routine producer for one product and own valuable technology for another. The Directive’s tested-party illustration accordingly changes the tested party when the valuable intangible and routine distribution functions move between parties. The Nepal entity is not automatically selected in every case.
Use one comparable measure
Operating profit is income after direct and indirect expenses but before interest and tax. Divide it by an appropriate cost, sales or operating-asset base, using the corresponding basis for comparables. An operating margin on sales is not interchangeable with a return on cost; 10% of one denominator does not mean 10% of the other.
Consider business experience, market conditions, strategy, cost structure and other material factors affecting the ratio, making supportable adjustments. The method may help where dependable gross-margin data are unavailable, but it still requires comparability. It does not convert the average of any available companies into the taxpayer’s required return.
For related-party sales, the original Nepali method adds the appropriate net profit to the relevant costs to derive revenue. For related-party purchases, it works back from independent resale proceeds after the appropriate profit analysis. Keep that direction consistent with the actual transaction.
Key points
This ordinary comparability example does not itself qualify a business for the new section 33A route. Apply that provision’s own relationship, activity and other conditions separately.
Original Directive example 5.4.1 - adjustment before comparison
Kasthamandap Ltd. provides IT services to US parent California Inc. Its stated net operating-profit ratio is 15%. Five independent comparables average 17%; the example adjusts their higher experience-related profitability by 3 percentage points, producing 14%. Since 15% exceeds that adjusted comparator, the source records zero adjustment.
The example does not identify the ratio’s denominator. It therefore cannot establish a 15%-of-cost benchmark. The original Nepali narrative and table use 3%; the English narrative’s “34 times” is a translation error, not an additional adjustment. No income year is specified.
Application: Example 5.4.1 reports zero on its stated comparison. It does not set out the indicator’s denominator or the full section 5.6 tolerance calculation. For an actual transaction, apply section 5.6’s upper and lower limits separately; being above the example’s adjusted comparator is not a general acceptance rule.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text
Profit-split transfer pricing: divide combined profit by actual contributions
Where related parties make unique contributions to an integrated transaction, testing only one party’s routine margin may miss the economic arrangement. The profit-split method first establishes combined transaction profit or loss, then allocates it on an arm’s-length basis.
When a combined analysis is appropriate
The specialist Directive identifies transactions involving unique and significant contributions, inseparable integration, economically significant risks borne by both sides, or business intangibles used by both. Common ownership alone does not establish those features. Nor does an agreement naming a convenient percentage prove that independent parties would divide the result in that way.
Where suitable uncontrolled transactions exist, examine how independent persons divide profits on the important economic bases needed to earn them. If comparables are unavailable, use the relative value of functions performed, assets used and risks assumed from the comparability analysis.
For arrangements with more than two related parties, the Directive first allows an ordinary arm’s-length return to less complex parties without intangibles under other appropriate methods. Allocate the remaining profit under the profit-split approach. Avoid allocating the same total profit again after routine returns have already been rewarded.
Choose an allocation factor connected to value
Asset-based or cost-based factors can be useful only where they reflect contributions to value creation. The Directive links relevant tangible or intangible assets to asset-based factors, and discusses marketing costs or research-and-development costs where those costs relate to the relevant intangible. The largest accounting expense does not automatically represent the largest contribution.
Establish the combined profit for the controlled transaction before assigning the share. Then distinguish the allocated profit from the recipient’s revenue: add its relevant costs where the example’s revenue calculation requires that step. A 20% profit share is not necessarily 20% of the customer’s contract price.
Key points
The work percentages are assumptions of this hypothetical illustration, not a statutory formula for every multinational. They must not replace the actual contribution analysis or the conditions of a separate statutory route.
Original Directive example 5.5.1 - software development
Florida Incorporation has a USD 200,000,000 software contract. Its assumed work allocation is 50% to itself, 30% to its Indian subsidiary and 20% to its Nepal subsidiary. Combined profit is USD 60,000,000. The Nepal company incurs USD 10,000,000 costs and bills USD 15,000,000.
Using the source’s assumed contribution, Nepal’s profit share is 60,000,000 × 20% = USD 12,000,000. Add its USD 10,000,000 costs: arm’s-length revenue is USD 22,000,000. The shortfall against its USD 15,000,000 invoice is USD 7,000,000. No income year is stated.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text
Transfer-pricing ranges: seven comparables use a different test from six
The specialist Directive uses a range where at least seven comparables are available and an arithmetic mean where there are six or fewer. Its 5% tolerance is relative to the relevant indicator; it is not five percentage points or Finance Act 2083’s statutory safe harbour.
Seven or more: range, tolerance, then median
Section 5.6 uses the 35th and 65th percentile positions, not a substituted 25th-to-75th percentile convention. Order the comparable indicators and apply the Directive’s ranking approach. The tested indicator is accepted inside that range or within 5% below its lower indicator or within 5% above its upper indicator.
If it falls outside the permitted tolerance, compare with the dataset median. The adjustment is to that median, not merely to the nearest boundary. Choosing a different spreadsheet percentile convention can therefore change both the acceptance decision and the eventual adjustment.
Six or fewer: test against the mean
Calculate the arithmetic mean of comparable indicators. An indicator within 5% above or below that mean is accepted. Outside it, use the difference from the mean. Both an upper and a lower limit apply; an illustration discussing only the lower end does not remove the upper limit.
A percentage-point difference becomes a monetary adjustment only when applied to the correct financial base. Do not report a rupee adjustment from margin figures without identifying whether the indicator uses sales, costs or another base.
Key points
These undated Directive illustrations assume the comparables are suitable. Neither tolerance repairs an unsuitable comparison, supplies an example’s missing financial base, nor establishes eligibility under section 33A.
Original example 5.6.1 - eight comparables
Api Ltd.’s eight margins, sorted, are 5.32%, 6%, 7.71%, 9.86%, 10.87%, 12.44%, 21.30% and 36.13%. The source uses 8 × 35% = 2.8 and 8 × 65% = 5.2, taking the third and sixth observations: 7.71%-12.44%.
Its 8% and 7.5% cases are accepted; 4% is outside tolerance. The median is (9.86% + 10.87%)/2 = 10.365%, rounded to 10.37%. The source’s rounded adjustment is 10.37% - 4% = 6.37 percentage points.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text
Original example 5.6.2 - five comparables
Alpha Ltd.’s five margins are 12.44%, 6%, 9.86%, 10.87% and 36.13%. Their mean is 15.06%; against actual 10%, the difference is 5.06 percentage points. The original Nepali conclusion confirms 5.06; the English final sentence’s 5.05 is erroneous.
Separate C.M. & Associates calculation: the exact tolerance limits are 15.06% × 95% = 14.307% and 15.06% × 105% = 15.813%. The source rounds the lower figure to 14.3%; its lower-only case must be read with section 5.6’s two-sided rule.
Source: Transfer Pricing Directives, 2081 - original Nepali text