Selling part of an asset: allocate cost and preserve the balance
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
A part sale does not normally use the whole original tax cost.
Two allocation situations have different dates
Section 49(1) applies when assets or liabilities are acquired, assumed or disposed of together. Relevant expenditure or incomings must be allocated between them by market values at the acquisition, assumption or disposal time. One agreement and one invoice do not turn different assets into a single undivided tax cost.
Section 49(2) concerns disposal of only part of an asset or liability. Allocate its net outgoings or net incomings immediately before disposal between the part disposed of and the part retained, using their market values immediately after disposal. Keep that post-disposal valuation point distinct from the historical purchase date.
Equal physical size can have unequal value
Two equal land areas can have different access, frontage or development rights. If their market values differ, dividing cost into equal halves can overstate one disposal cost and understate the retained balance. The Directive illustrates precisely that difference: equal ropani do not result in equal cost allocation.
The allocated cost of the sold part enters its disposal working. The remaining amount stays with the retained part for later computation; it must not be deducted again in the first sale. This allocation determines amounts, not whether the asset is taxable or the applicable collection/final-tax rate.
The same statutory distinction also matters to liabilities and joint transactions. First identify the actual rights or burdens transferred. A temporary right and a permanent division may engage different disposal rules before section 49 assigns the corresponding amounts.
Key points
- Section 49 uses market values, not automatically land area or unit count.
- The retained cost must reconcile with the amount allocated to the disposal.
Directive example22.17.2: two equal ropani, different values
Laxmi Finance, Pokhara, purchases two ropani for Rs 10000000 and pays Rs 500,000 for survey, market-value and legal work. Total outgoings are Rs 10500000. It sells one ropani for Rs 12000000; the retained ropani is worth Rs 8000000. The 60:40 market-value split allocates Rs 6300000 cost to the sold portion and Rs 4200000 to the retained land. The two allocated amounts reconcile to Rs 10500000. No income year is specified.
Current legal position
For a joint acquisition, example 22.17.1 allocates Rs 300,000 common cost over land valued at Rs 10000000 and Rs 5000000 as Rs 200,000 and Rs 100,000. Apply the relevant valuation date and weights rather than reuse a convenient equal split.
Dividing a right or burden: permanent and temporary treatment
Section 48 first asks whether the right or burden transferred is permanent.
Identify what the other person receives
Section 48 concerns rights relating to an owned asset or burdens relating to an existing liability being created in another person, including through a lease of all or part of an asset. It distinguishes permanent rights/burdens from temporary or contingent ones. The question is the legal interest created, not simply whether the contract describes a parcel, a room or a percentage.
If the rights or burdens are permanent, the original person is treated as disposing of part of the asset or liability, but not as acquiring a new asset or liability. That conclusion identifies a part-disposal; it does not itself calculate the gain. The applicable proceeds, cost-allocation and asset-category rules still supply that calculation.
A temporary grant has a different result
If the rights or burdens are temporary or contingent, the original person is not treated as disposing of part of the underlying asset or liability. Depending on the circumstances, however, the person is treated as acquiring a new asset or assuming a new liability. Keeping the original land or obligation therefore does not mean nothing happened for tax purposes.
Payments for a temporary use right may fall within the applicable rental, royalty or business-income rules. Section 48 is not a blanket exemption for rent, lease premiums or other consideration. The newly created right or burden must be analysed according to its own character.
This is also distinct from section 49. Section 48 identifies the consequence of dividing rights or burdens;49 allocates the relevant incomings/outgoings where a part is disposed of. Starting with a cost fraction cannot replace the earlier decision about whether a permanent part-disposal occurred.
Key points
- A temporary grant need not dispose of part of the underlying asset.
- No part-disposal does not mean the new right or its payment is tax-free.
Directive 22.16: original nonmonetary comparison
The Directive contrasts permanently separating and transferring part of a plot with giving property temporarily under an operating lease. The permanent transfer is a division-related disposal of part of the land; the operating-lease explanation does not treat it as disposal of part of the owned property. It supplies no numbered rupee example for this distinction.
Current legal position
A permanent division, temporary use and a finance lease need their respective provisions. Section 48 does not turn every lease into the same tax event.