Selling below the usual price: establish the VAT value
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
A price far below prevailing market value can trigger section 12(6), including where the buyer is connected with the seller.
Identify the actual valuation question
Section 12(1) generally uses the supplier’s price where consideration consists only of cash, subject to the Act’s other rules. Section 12(6) substitutes market value where the price appears excessively below prevailing market value. Section 12(7) also addresses a supply for partial consideration. A sale within a business group therefore deserves an evidence-based review, rather than an assumption that either the invoice amount or a group policy automatically settles the VAT value. Directive clause 4.12 specifically warns about personal or financial connections depressing consideration and uses the independent market-value principle to establish the actual tax liability.
Choose a real comparison
Section 13 asks what consideration arises for similar goods or services supplied independently between unrelated persons. Rule 22 directs the officer to study similar registered sellers’ transactions and prices. The Directive discusses comparable goods, quantity, quality, specifications, location and timing. Preserve independent sales or quotations and explain material differences in the transaction terms. If the prescribed comparison cannot determine the value, section 13 and Rule 22 provide the Director General’s determination route. A convenient retail sticker price is not automatically the right comparison for every wholesale supply.
Key points
- Market value uses comparable independent transactions; a relationship label alone does not supply the valuation.
- Genuine commercial discounts need evidence. They should not be confused with an unsupported low invoice price.
Distinguish a discount from undervaluation
Section 12(3) excludes the stated discount, commission or similar trade reduction from taxable value. Directive clause 5.10 recognizes a public commercial discount policy and explains why legitimate pricing can differ between businesses. The taxpayer must support the difference and its basis. Keep the policy, eligibility, invoice treatment and evidence of its actual application. A retrospective explanation written only for a connected buyer is different from a demonstrable commercial arrangement. The Act does not supply an automatic percentage tolerance for a low price.
Retain a usable valuation file
Record the parties, goods or services, supply date, agreed consideration, comparator evidence and reason for adjustments. Separate the VAT conclusion from income-tax transfer-pricing documentation and financial-reporting values. Those records may help explain facts, but their legal tests do not replace sections 12 and 13. Seek a specific determination where the facts or comparison remain unresolved; do not disguise a valuation difference by recording a smaller quantity supplied.
Directive explanation 5.10: market comparisons and discounts
The Directive describes market value as an independent unrelated-party price. It recognizes that a published commercial discount policy can create a legitimate difference, while requiring the taxpayer to substantiate that difference. This is an unnumbered explanation, not a numerical IRD example.
C.M. & Associates illustration: a group wholesaler
A wholesaler sells to an associated shop at a lower price than small retail customers pay. Compare independent wholesale transactions with similar quantities and terms before concluding that the retail price is the market value. This illustration supplies no automatic discount percentage or legal safe harbour.
Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.
Current legal position
The selected valuation provisions remain in the checked 2080-2082 Acts and the 2083 overlays. This article gives no universal related-party uplift, permitted discount percentage or replacement for a fact-specific market-value determination.
Under-invoicing can expose remaining stock to statutory purchase
Section 23ग concerns like-kind goods remaining in stock after an under-invoiced sale.
Identify the specific stock and the power
A low-price dispute can have a consequence beyond increasing the VAT value of a past sale. Section 23ग(1) applies where a person has sold goods by showing a selling price below prevailing market value through under-invoicing. It permits the officer to restrict like-kind goods remaining in stock and purchase, or cause purchase of, them at the price used for the under-invoiced sale. The statutory link is to that sale and that kind of remaining goods.
This power is framed around goods and stock. It should not be translated into a compulsory purchase of an intangible service or every asset owned by the seller. Establish whether the alleged past sale, price and remaining goods actually match the statutory description. The separate market-value analysis in sections 12 and 13 still matters; a supported commercial discount is not automatically an established under-invoice.
Read refusal, possession and payment together
If the person refuses to sell when the officer purchases or causes purchase under subsection (1), subsection (2) permits the officer to take the goods into possession. The officer must calculate on the under-invoiced selling-price basis and pay when that person comes to receive payment. This subsection describes a purchase-price payment, distinct from a tax or penalty assessment.
Subsection (3) permits later sale under the price and procedure prescribed by the Director General. The VAT Directive identifies a separate 2074 purchase-and-sale Directive. This explanation sets out the statutory consequence; it does not establish the detailed implementation of that separate procedure. Ordinary recovery of an existing tax debt and its property-auction rules are separate questions.
Key points
- The statutory purchase price follows the under-invoiced sale price.
- Refusal to sell does not itself prevent the possession-and-payment mechanism.
C.M. & Associates illustration: like-kind remaining goods
An officer alleges that a dealer under-invoiced a particular product and identifies remaining units of that kind. Section 23ग requires that link. It does not, merely because those units exist, establish the statutory basis to buy an unrelated machine in the same warehouse.
Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.
Current legal position
The selected section 23ग wording continues through the 2079-2082 Acts. Finance 2083 does not amend it. The prescribed purchase/resale implementation must be established separately.