Second-hand goods: when VAT applies to the margin

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

A registered second-hand dealer must examine the special method in section 17(5) and Rules 33 and 44.

A special method, with specific records

A dealer buying used goods from consumers may have no ordinary VAT purchase invoice. Section 17(5) provides for prescribed treatment of registered persons dealing in used goods. Rule 33 assesses VAT on the difference between selling and purchase prices and requires permanent purchase and sales records prepared at the transaction. Do not assume that every disposal of a business's own old asset qualifies for this dealer method. First identify the activity and the applicable provisions.

Record each item's identity, purchase and sale dates, purchase and selling amounts, relevant tax and totals paid or received. Rule 33(2) defines purchase price for this purpose as tax-inclusive. Keep the original acquisition evidence so that the price cannot be replaced by an unsupported estimated cost. A repair bill is a separate transaction; do not automatically add repairs or general overheads to the statutory purchase-price deduction.

Do not combine incompatible credit assumptions

Rule 44 restricts purchase credit for used goods acquired from an unregistered person and its stated category of goods acquired from registered persons that were also put to personal use. Apply the actual category and wording. The existence of VAT registration somewhere in the chain does not itself establish the dealer's ordinary credit entitlement. Equally, the rule should not be paraphrased as a universal prohibition on every purchase involving something second-hand.

Issue an invoice for each used item sold and retain separate purchase and sales records. Under Rule 33(4), unsatisfactory prescribed records can lead the officer to order tax on the total selling price for payment with the next return. The evidence supporting the margin is therefore part of the method itself, not an optional explanation prepared only after an enquiry.

Key points

  • The margin treatment depends on item-level records. An ordinary input-credit claim is not automatically available.

Directive example 7.7: a used Tucson

Apar International Pvt. Ltd. deals in used vehicles, motorcycles, televisions and refrigerators. It buys a Tucson from Ram Bahadur of Dhapasi for Rs 2,000,000, undertakes ordinary repairs and sells it to Hari Bahadur of New Baneshwor for Rs 2,500,000. The Directive charges VAT on the Rs 500,000 difference. It gives no specific year or repair amount. Those facts are preserved; no repair-cost deduction or additional tax calculation has been inserted.

Source: IRD VAT Directives 2069, third amendment 2080

Current legal position

The historical example remains subject to section 17(5) and Rules 33 and 44. The checked Finance Act 2083 and twenty-eighth Rules amendment do not change that gateway or those two Rules. The margin method does not make the goods exempt or create an additional ordinary purchase-credit entitlement.

Sources and references