Recovering a salary advance does not reduce payroll tax

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

Calculate payroll tax before deciding how to recover an employee advance.

Two separate payroll calculations

An employer may need to recover money advanced to an employee while also deducting salary tax. Those are separate entries. Section 87(2) says the employer’s withholding obligation is not reduced or extinguished because it has a right or duty to deduct, retain or reduce another amount from the payment.

First calculate the employee’s employment income and applicable annual tax. Rule 31 requires the relevant annual payroll calculation to be reflected in withholding. Then show tax, advance recovery, other authorised deductions and cash payment separately. Reducing cash by an advance recovery does not, by itself, reduce taxable remuneration.

When the proposed recovery leaves too little cash

Prepare the payroll reconciliation before releasing payment. Establish the current tax requirement and the advance balance from the original payment and recovery records. If the proposed recovery leaves less cash than the required withholding, do not solve the shortage by treating the tax as nil.

The employer should resolve the lawful recovery amount and schedule while keeping the tax obligation visible. Whether a particular deduction is permitted depends on the applicable employment and wage law and the actual arrangement. Section 87 preserves a tax duty; it does not grant a separate right to recover any amount from wages.

Retain the advance approval, employee account, repayment arrangement, payroll working and tax deposit/reporting evidence. An advance repaid through payroll is not the same as correcting an earlier overstated salary: an actual income error needs its own supporting record.

Key points

  • A small remaining cash salary does not cancel the employer’s withholding duty.
  • The tax rule does not itself authorise an otherwise unlawful wage deduction.

Authentic Directive example 16.2.3: FY2080/81

A Nepal Sewa Bank employee earns Rs 50,000 monthly. The example assumes monthly salary tax of Rs 4,500. In Ashadh 2081, the bank proposes to recover Rs 48,000 of advances, leaving only Rs 2,000 before tax. The Directive says the bank must still deduct and deposit Rs 4,500. The tax figure is assumed in the example, not calculated from current bands.

Source: IRD Income Tax Directives2066, Fifth Amendment2081

Current legal position

For a current payroll, use the applicable year’s remuneration, benefits, deductions, credits and Schedule 1 rates. The historical Rs 4,500 is not a verified FY2083/84 tax on Rs 50,000 monthly salary.

Schedule 1, section 1(1)-(2): resident individual and couple bands

Before: The Act through Finance 2082 used a first band of Rs 500,000 for an individual and Rs 600,000 for an electing couple, followed by the applicable 10%,20%,30%,36% and 39% marginal bands.

Change: Finance 2083 replaces the bands with a common structure: first Rs 1,000,000 at 1%, next Rs 500,000 at 10%, next Rs 1,000,000 at 20%, next Rs 1,500,000 at 27%, and excess over Rs 4,000,000 at 29%. Statutory first-band exceptions still need examination.

Instrument: Finance Act 2083, section 57(26), PDF211-212; earlier wording in Act 2082 PDF157-158.

Effective date: 2083 Shrawan 1 under Finance 2083 section 1(2), PDF2; section 57 is outside the immediately commencing list.

Practical effect: Use the applicable current annual calculation rather than the historical example tax or band equation.

Sources and references