Paying for extraction rights: natural-resource payments are not ordinary rent or royalty
Prepared by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants
An extraction right can fall within the natural-resource definition even before output is produced.
Apply both natural-resource limbs
Section 2(श) covers payment for obtaining the right to extract water, minerals or other living or non-living resources from land. Its second limb covers an amount calculated by reference to the quantity or value of the specified resources extracted wholly or partly from land. These are alternatives. A fixed payment for the extraction right need not be calculated per tonne to enter the first limb.
Conversely, a quantity- or value-based payment must be connected to the extraction described by the definition. An invoice calculated by quantity is not automatically a natural-resource payment: ordinary purchases of finished goods also use quantities. Establish the right granted and what the amount is paid for, rather than importing the category from a commercial label.
Separate access to land from extraction and intellectual property
The rent definition concerns premiums and other payments under leases of tangible property, subject to its express exceptions. A royalty generally concerns intangible-property leasing and the listed rights, knowledge, experience, ancillary assistance or restraints. Both definitions expressly exclude natural-resource payments. Calling an extraction payment land rent or a mineral royalty in the contract does not remove that statutory exclusion.
An arrangement can nevertheless involve separate supplies: use of premises or equipment, an extraction right and a technology licence need not represent the same right. Identify genuine components and their consideration. These definitions do not prescribe an arbitrary percentage for splitting a composite fee, and a mineral purchase should not be reclassified solely because its supplier operates a quarry.
After classifying the receipt, apply the business or investment inclusion and relevant source provisions. Section 67 has a distinct natural-resource source connection, but source follows a different question from what the payment is. A withholding result, treaty classification, expenditure deduction or extraction permission requires its own applicable provision; none is granted by the definition alone.
Key points
- An output-based payment has its own quantity-or-value limb.
- The rent and royalty definitions expressly exclude natural-resource payments.
Directive source box: extraction and royalty are different categories
The Directive repeats the two natural-resource limbs in its Chapter 2 explanation. Its separate royalty explanation illustrates a payment to a singer, lyricist or composer when a radio station plays a song. This is an intangible-right illustration, not an extraction payment. Neither explanation supplies a resource tariff, a rupee computation or an income year.
Current legal position
Read the actual rights before choosing the payment category. The statutory exclusions prevent a natural-resource payment from being treated as ordinary rent or royalty merely because the invoice uses those words.