Goods returned after VAT filing: reconcile acceptance, stock and the note

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

A later return does not erase the original sale or filed record.

Establish what actually changed

Begin with the original invoice and agreement. Identify the goods, quantities, reason for return and the seller’s acceptance or price settlement. A transport receipt proves movement; it does not alone establish agreement to reverse the entire sale. A buyer’s internal debit note communicates a claim but cannot replace the supplier’s corresponding lawful record. Preserve the disputed balance separately.

Check whether this is a partial return, complete return, replacement or price change without physical return. Directive clause 5.9 distinguishes these situations. Where returned goods are exchanged for higher-priced goods, it describes a credit note for the original goods and a tax invoice for the new supply. Do not disguise two different supplies as an unexplained net difference.

Connect the adjustment to the original period record

The original sale and filed return remain part of the audit trail. Rule 20 requires a clearly identified, sequentially numbered and dated credit/debit note naming the parties, original invoice number/date, goods or services, reason, adjusted value and VAT. Clause 5.9 applies the original supply’s tax rate and records the adjustment in the relevant period’s sales and purchase records. It does not permit placing a note in any period merely to obtain a desired balance.

A later genuine return differs from discovering that the original return contained an error. Document which event occurred before deciding the applicable reporting treatment. The note does not itself authorize rewriting a filed return, using an unverified portal workflow or ignoring a legal correction procedure. Match the original invoice, filing, later note and current reconciliation so the same tax is adjusted only once.

Key points

  • Separate accepted quantities from goods still disputed.
  • Link the seller’s credit note, buyer’s adjustment and stock movement once.

Follow the stock and settlement

Keep the return request, dispatch and receipt evidence, inspection or acceptance and warehouse entries. For a partial return, the Directive requires the original purchase and stock receipt to be recorded, the returned quantity/value/tax identified, the invoice copy retained and both parties’ notes reflected in their records. The purchase-side tax adjustment matters where the buyer originally claimed credit.

Then reconcile the customer balance: cash refund, later offset or outstanding amount. Record whether goods are repaired, replaced, resold or retained as disputed stock. Rule 23 requires supporting value-change documents, generally retained six years. A bad debt with the customer keeping the goods is a different issue from a supported goods return.

Directive clause 5.9(घ)-(ङ) - unnumbered partial-return illustration

For some goods returned from one invoice, the Directive records the original purchase and stock receipt, identifies the returned goods and value with an invoice copy, and uses the buyer’s debit note and seller’s credit note in their respective purchase and sales records. No amount or year is supplied.

Source: IRD VAT Directives 2069, third amendment 2080

C.M. & Associates illustration - partial acceptance

Assume 100 units were invoiced at Rs. 1,000 each plus 13% VAT and already reported. The buyer sends back 20 units; the seller accepts 15 and disputes five. For the accepted 15 only, the assumed credit is Rs. 15,000 plus Rs. 1,950 VAT, total Rs. 16,950. Keep the other five units and claim separately identifiable until resolved. This firm illustration does not decide the contractual dispute.

Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.

Current legal position

Use the current Department-prescribed sales-book format. The note, stock movement and settlement should explain the same event without deleting the original invoice or taking duplicate VAT relief.

Sales-book record for adjustment notes

Before: Rule 23(1)(ज) required the sales book in Schedule 9; the separate duty to retain credit/debit notes and supporting documents was already in Rule 23(1)(च).

Change: The 28th Amendment replaces the sales-book wording with the format prescribed by the Department and repeals Schedule 9. Rule 20 note particulars and monthly records continue.

Instrument: VAT twenty-eighth amendment Rules 2083, rules 3 and 8, original PDF 1-3.

Effective date: Immediately under rule 1(2); Gazette 2083/02/15.

Practical effect: Keep the adjustment linked to the current prescribed sales record; do not describe the repealed Schedule 9 as the current mandatory format.

Sources and references
  • VAT Act 2052 through Finance 2082

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Section 12(1)-(3), PDF 13; sections 14 and 16-17, PDF 14-18. Actual supply-time/rate governs the adjustment; ordinary 13% assumed only in firm illustrations.

  • VAT Rules 2053 through twenty-seventh amendment

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Rule 20(1)-(2), PDF 12; Rule 23(1)(च), (7), PDF 13-14. Pre-28th sales-book wording is superseded by G28.

  • IRD VAT Directives 2069, third amendment 2080

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Clause 5.9, PDF/printed 93-95: whole/partial returns, buyer and seller notes, genuine later price adjustment, unregistered buyer and original supply rate. These procedural illustrations have no numbered example or invented amounts.

  • VAT twenty-eighth amendment Rules 2083, original Gazette

    Authority / publisher: Department of Printing - Nepal Gazette

    Relevant information: Rules 1-3 and 8, PDF 1-3; Rule 23(1)(ज) department-prescribed sales book replaces Schedule 9 wording and Schedule 9 is repealed. Immediate commencement, Gazette 2083/02/15.