Does tax already deducted mean no income-tax return is needed?

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

Withholding and return exemption are different legal questions.

Test the current exception, not the payment voucher

Section 97(1), replaced by Finance 2083, lists persons who need not submit a section 96 return. It includes the specified person not liable to tax, a final-withholding recipient, a resident natural person covered by section 4(3), the specified non-sole-proprietor vehicle owner and persons prescribed by the Department. A deduction at source is not necessarily final withholding.

The former standalone exceptions for certain section 95A-only receipts and persons choosing not to file with only non-business taxable-asset disposal income are absent from the replacement list. Check whether another current exception actually applies. Advance collection on a receipt does not itself settle that question.

Employment-only is a combined test

Section 4(3) requires only Nepal-source employment income, all employers to be resident and only one employer at a time. It also restricts deduction/credit claims: the specified employer-paid medical credit and employer-paid retirement contribution are allowed within this route, while a section 12 donation deduction is not claimed. Having salary tax deducted is only part of the test. Sequential employers are different from two employers at the same time.

There are two important overrides. The Department can require a return through written order or public notice. Separately, section 97(2) requires a natural person with income above Rs 4000000 in an income year to file despite subsection(1). Exactly Rs 4000000 is not above that threshold, but other filing grounds may still apply.

Filing under that override does not automatically tax every disclosed receipt again. Sections 97(3)-(4) govern the additional income disclosure and exclusions, including specified final-withholding and concession income. Apply those rules rather than adding every receipt to ordinary taxable salary.

Key points

  • Employment-only treatment has several cumulative conditions.
  • A Department demand or income above Rs 4000000 can require filing despite an ordinary exception.

Authentic Directive discussion 25.3: tax payable can be nil

The Directive distinguishes a person with no taxable-income activity from a person carrying on such activity who makes a loss or earns below the tax-paying level. It says the latter still files. It also explains that employment-only treatment cannot simply be carried over when business or investment income is present. These are the source’s explanations, not numbered monetary examples.

Source: Income Tax Directives2066, Fifth Amendment2081

Current legal position

Use the Finance 2083 replacement list, not the older Directive list. Exemption from filing is not a general exemption from tax or from a specific Department demand.

Sections 97(3) and 117(1)(d)

Before: The 97(3) optional-inclusion proviso mentioned meeting allowances and interest; there was no specific 117(1)(d) fee for 97(2) returns.

Change: Retirement payments are added to the 97(3) optional-inclusion proviso. A specific failure-to-file fee is added for 97(2): the higher of 0.1% per year of assessable income after subtracting final-withholding income, or Rs 1,200 per return, with Rs 100 per month for a period shorter than a year.

Instrument: Finance 2082, section 37(12),(14), PDF 171.

Effective date: 2082 Shrawan 1 under section 1(2), PDF 1; section 37 is outside the immediate list.

Practical effect: Income disclosure and the consequences of missing a compulsory 97(2) return must use the amended wording; it does not create a blanket retirement-income filing exemption.

Section 97(1), return-filing exceptions

Before: The earlier list separately included certain section 95A-only income recipients and persons choosing not to file with only non-business taxable-asset disposal income.

Change: The list is replaced. It retains the no-tax, final-withholding, section 4(3) employment and specified vehicle-owner categories, adds persons prescribed by the Department and preserves written/public notice power to require filing. The two earlier separate categories are not retained as such.

Instrument: Finance 2083, section 57(22), PDF 210-211.

Effective date: 2083 Shrawan 1 under section 1(2), PDF 2.

Practical effect: Do not rely on a removed category or assume advance tax by itself excuses filing. Test current categories and the over-Rs 4000000 override.

Sources and references