Dividends from outside profit: the entity's own income-tax charge
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
Section 56(3) addresses the entity's income, not only shareholder withholding.
Identify the amount actually distributed
An entity may describe a payment as dividend even though the amount did not come from its profit. Section 56(3) requires that dividend amount to be included when computing the entity's income, subject to the prescribed exception. Paying it from a reserve or another account does not itself remove the tax consequence. The actual statutory character of the payment matters.
This rule must be distinguished from a genuine return of capital. Section 53 distinguishes distributions of profit, capitalisation and capital returned. A payment cannot be placed outside profit merely by changing its ledger name; nor is every capital payment automatically a dividend. Determine that classification before applying section 56(3).
The exception has a matching expense restriction
Rule 18 concerns a dividend outside profit arising, otherwise than in carrying on the entity's business, through services provided to a beneficiary or entity-owned property made available for that beneficiary's use. In those prescribed circumstances, the dividend need not be added to the entity's income under section 56(3).
However, Rule 18(2) disallows every related deduction, including depreciation, for that service or property. It is therefore not permission to leave the benefit outside income while also deducting its associated private-use costs. This exception addresses a defined benefit arrangement, not every cash distribution from an account labelled capital.
The recipient's distribution rules and any withholding must still be examined separately. Companies Act permission to declare or distribute value is also a separate question. An income-tax inclusion neither validates the corporate decision nor makes a prohibited dividend lawful.
Key points
- A narrow Rule 18 exception is paired with denial of related deductions.
- Tax treatment does not authorise a distribution prohibited by company law.
CMA illustration applying section56(3), not an IRD example
Assume an amount of Rs 100,000 is legally characterised as a dividend from outside profit and does not satisfy Rule 18. Section 56(3) adds Rs 100,000 to the entity's income computation. If instead the facts satisfy the Rule 18 service/property-use exception, that particular addition does not arise, but deductions relating to the service or property are denied. These assumptions do not determine the recipient's tax.
Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.
Current legal position
The Directive explains this inclusion at clause 13.9. Read the entity inclusion, Rule 18 expense denial and beneficiary treatment together; a lack of accounting profit is not a general escape from distribution tax.