Billing software penalties: different rules for the taxpayer and the provider

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

An electronic-invoice user and a software manufacturer, installer or operator face distinct statutory tests.

The electronic-invoice user’s rule

Under the substituted section 119A (1), a taxpayer issuing electronic invoices under section 81(4) faces a Rs 500,000 fee for using software whose data can be deleted or altered. Failure to comply with the other provisions of section 81 carries a Rs 100,000 fee under that subsection. The first question is therefore which statutory duty was breached, not simply whether a computer was involved.

The expression “deletable or alterable” comes from the statutory rule. A general claim that software is reliable, or that the supplier is familiar with tax work, does not answer whether the actual invoicing arrangement satisfies section 81 and the applicable Department requirements. Conversely, a fee should be tied to the actual legal provision and conduct, rather than to an undifferentiated allegation of poor bookkeeping.

The provider has a separate duty

Section 119A (2) concerns a person who manufactures, installs or operates electronic-invoice software or equipment under section 81(4). Failure to follow the procedure issued by the Department attracts a Rs 500,000 fee. This is a provider-side compliance test, separate from the taxpayer’s use of tamperable software. Finance 2083’s replacement of subsection (1) leaves this separate subsection intact.

A supplier’s invoice or assurance cannot transfer the taxpayer’s own statutory responsibility. Nor does a taxpayer’s default establish, without examining the procedure and the supplier’s conduct, that the provider necessarily committed the subsection (2) breach. Where one person acts in more than one capacity, each allegation still needs its own statutory basis.

Key points

  • Finance 2083 replaced the user-side clause. It did not turn every software failure into the same Rs 500,000 charge.

Keep other charges separate

The Act separately addresses business receipts through personal accounts in section 81A and 119A (3), and residual noncompliance in 119A (4). Those provisions should not replace the specific current section 81 rule. Section 122 also requires the Department’s written assessment to explain why a fee is imposed, its amount, computation and challenge route.

This article concerns income-tax duties. It does not reproduce a VAT penalty or assume that satisfying one tax regime automatically satisfies another.

Directive explanation - electronic invoicing is a statutory system

The Directive’s records discussion explains the Department’s power under section 81(4) to prescribe electronic invoicing and the associated software and equipment conditions. That discussion supplies the statutory background; the current Rs 500,000/Rs 100,000 user distinction comes from the later Finance 2083 amendment, not a numbered Directive example.

Source: Income Tax Directives 2066, Fifth Amendment 2081

Current legal position

Apply the Finance 2083 replacement from 1 Shrawan 2083 to the user-side rule, and read the separate provider duty in 119A (2). This does not certify any product or a particular Department approval.

Section 81(4)-(6), linked billing system

Before: Section 81(4) allowed approval to issue electronic invoices and keep records electronically; section 81(5) addressed mandatory electronic invoicing linked to CBMS; section 81(6) expressly required producers, distributors and users to follow the Department procedure.

Change: The electronic-record phrase in 81(4) was replaced by power to make necessary arrangements; section 81(5) now also permits an order to use the Department-provided billing system; the express last sentence of 81(6) was deleted. Section 119A (2)’s provider noncompliance fee remains separate.

Instrument: Finance Act 2083, section 57(15), PDF 207.

Effective date: 1 Shrawan 2083 under 1(2), PDF 2.

Practical effect: Read the amended underlying billing duties and the specific charging provision together; the old Directive wording is historical.

Section 119A replacement

Before: The through 2080 section 119A contained the residual Rs 5, 000-Rs 25,000 noncompliance fee without the later separate electronic-invoice user/provider subsections.

Change: The replacement added Rs 500,000 user and provider rules, the separate 81A charge, and retained a residual noncompliance subsection.

Instrument: Finance Act 2081, section 36(18), PDF 247-248.

Effective date: 1 Shrawan 2081 under 1(2), PDF 2.

Practical effect: Do not use the former residual clause as the complete current billing-software rule.

Section 119A (1)

Before: The through 2082 text charged Rs 500,000 where an approved or unapproved electronic-invoice taxpayer used software in which data could be deleted or altered.

Change: Finance 2083 replaces subsection (1): an electronic-invoice issuer under 81(4) using deletable or alterable software faces Rs 500,000; failure to comply with other provisions of section 81 carries Rs 100,000. It does not replace the separate provider clause 119A (2).

Instrument: Finance Act 2083, section 57(25)

Effective date: 1 Shrawan 2083 under section 1(2).

Practical effect: Identify the violated duty and the person’s capacity before choosing the amount.

Sources and references