Accounting, Audit & Reporting
Auditor Appointment, Independence and Internal or Tax Audit - Choosing the Engagement
Start by deciding what the engagement needs to establish. Statutory audit, internal audit, tax certification and agreed-upon procedures serve different purposes and require different engagement terms. The appointment, scope and report should describe the service actually being commissioned.
Appointment and eligibility follow the applicable entity and professional law. Confirm the auditor's valid practising authority, independence, appointment decision, term and any rotation or disqualification rules for the entity/sector. A universal rotation interval should not be imposed across all entities without the relevant provision.
1. Engagement selection
| Engagement | Core purpose |
|---|---|
| Statutory audit | Independent opinion on financial statements under the applicable framework |
| Internal audit | Risk, governance and control evaluation under agreed mandate |
| Tax certification | Specified tax-law/form requirements and defined responsibility |
| Regulated-entity audit | Financial audit plus applicable sector instructions |
| NPO/cooperative audit | Relevant framework, law and fund/member/regulator requirements |
Keep management responsibility and auditor responsibility distinct. An internal auditor who designed a control may face objectivity considerations when reviewing it. Non-audit services can create independence threats for the external auditor and require assessment under the professional code.
Key points
- Choose the engagement from its purpose, users and required report before making the appointment.
- Set out independence, evidence and responsibility boundaries clearly; an agreed-upon procedures report presents factual findings rather than an assurance conclusion.
2. Nepal example
CMA illustration applying the provisions discussed in this article. Facts and figures are assumed; this is not an official IRD or court example.
An NPO asks its statutory auditor to certify donor expenditure and design its accounting controls. The firm first identifies separate scope and reporting criteria, evaluates competence and independence, and determines which services it can lawfully accept. A single engagement letter saying “all audit work” is insufficient to explain the different responsibilities.
3. Evidence and coordination
Retain appointment, acceptance, conflict checks, engagement terms, information requirements and communication with those charged with governance. Sector entities may need additional regulator formats or reporting; obtain the current instructions rather than reuse a bank, cooperative or insurance template interchangeably.
4. Completion
Issue the report appropriate to the engagement and preserve its criteria and limitations. Track internal-audit recommendations separately from an external opinion. Check current eligibility, rotation and prescribed reporting requirements for the entity.
5. Start with the purpose of the engagement
A statutory audit gives an independent opinion on financial statements under the applicable framework. Internal audit examines selected controls, risks or operations under an agreed mandate. A tax audit or tax-compliance review examines the tax treatment and supporting records for its particular purpose. The reports are different products, and one does not automatically discharge the obligations of another.
Before appointment, identify the entity's legal form, governing Act, shareholder or member requirements and any sector regulator. Confirm the appointment authority, the auditor's eligibility, required professional authorisation and the period covered. The engagement letter should describe responsibilities, scope, reporting framework, intended users and access to records. A fee quotation alone does not establish those terms.
6. Independence is a continuing assessment
Review relationships, financial interests, previous services and other circumstances that can create threats to independence. Preparing accounts, advising management and auditing the resulting statements can raise different considerations. The assessment should address the actual services and applicable professional rules rather than assuming that separate staff members resolve every concern.
Illustration applying the source rule
CMA illustration using assumed facts. The cited provisions and qualifications govern the analysis.
Suppose a Nepal company asks its bookkeeping provider to become statutory auditor. The proposed auditor assesses the prior work, management responsibilities, ethical restrictions and available safeguards before accepting. If the engagement cannot be performed with the required independence, a signed waiver from the client does not make the problem disappear. Preserve the conclusion and revisit it when relationships or services change.
7. Agree the report and responsibility boundaries
Management remains responsible for the records, accounting choices and financial statements. The auditor's role is to obtain evidence and report under the applicable standards. An internal-control recommendation should identify the issue and action owner without suggesting that the auditor has taken over management's control responsibilities.
Where a company needs both a statutory audit and help preparing a tax computation, define the separate work, permitted scope and review responsibility. An audit opinion does not promise that every tax position will be accepted by IRD. Keep the statutory appointment, engagement terms, independence conclusion and any separate advisory agreement together so that the resulting reports can be understood in context.
8. Appoint the company auditor through the right body
For a Nepal company, a fee agreement does not complete the statutory appointment. Companies Act sections 110-119 address appointment, disqualification, access, reporting and removal. First identify whether this is the first appointment, a later appointment, an inability to appoint or continue, or a proposed early removal. These are different routes.
Summary for company decision makers
First appointment and later appointments
Section 111(1) requires an auditor licensed under prevailing law. Its proviso assigns appointment before the first AGM to the board. For later appointments, a public company uses the general meeting, subject to Chapter 18. A private company follows an appointment arrangement in its memorandum, articles or unanimous agreement; if there is none, the general meeting appoints. Do not use a first-auditor board minute for a recurring appointment merely because the company is private.
The appointee holds office until the next AGM under section 111(2). Section 111(3) restricts public-company appointments beyond three consecutive occasions, extending to the stated partners, former partners, employees and former employees, subject to its three-year separation exception. It is not a universal three-year rule for every private company. Sector law and professional requirements must also be checked.
Eligibility before the decision
Section 112(1)(a)-(j) must be checked in full. Its exclusions include specified management, advisory, employment and family relationships; loans and overdue amounts; specified convictions and insolvency; basic shareholders or holders of at least 1% of paid-up capital and their close relatives; the rotation restriction; additional public-company employment and management-document roles; limited-liability companies or bodies corporate; and specified interests in company transactions. A general independence declaration is not a substitute for applying each relevant limb.
Under section 112(2), the proposed auditor supplies written information that they are not disqualified before appointment. If disqualification or inability to continue arises during the term, section 112(3) requires the auditor to stop the work immediately and notify the company in writing. An audit performed under an appointment contrary to section 112 is invalid under subsection (4).
Amendment box - section 113
Previously, where an AGM could not appoint, the AGM could not be held, or the appointed auditor could not remain, section 113 provided for OCR to appoint another auditor at the board's request. Section 7(8) of the Economic and Business Environment Improvement and Investment Enhancement Related Some Nepal Acts Amendment Act, 2081 inserts a distinction: the board of a private or unlisted public company may appoint another auditor with information to OCR; the OCR appointment route remains for listed public companies. Read the awkward inserted wording with the original amending clause, rather than deleting its surrounding conditions.
The amending Act was authenticated and Gazette-published on 18 Chaitra 2081 and commenced immediately under section 1(2). Gazette volume 74, extraordinary issue 62, Part 2 is the original instrument. Its later web listing is not a new effective date. The amendment does not state a general entitlement to reopen every earlier appointment or removal.
Early removal remains a separate controlled process
Section 119(1) protects the appointment until completion of the audit for the financial year concerned. Subsections (2)-(3) permit the specified misconduct, company-interest or legal-breach route only with prior information to ICAN, approval of the competent sector regulator where one exists or otherwise OCR, use of the appointment procedure, and a reasonable opportunity for the auditor to answer. A disagreement over an audit adjustment should not be relabelled as a vacancy to bypass these safeguards.
Illustration and completion file
CMA illustration with assumed facts: a newly formed private company has not held its first AGM. Its three-member board holds a valid meeting under its articles and section 97, having received the proposed auditor's section 112(2) information. The board appoints the eligible auditor and fixes remuneration under section 118. It records the actual decision, sends the name to OCR within 15 days and keeps the submission evidence. This illustration assumes no additional sector approval and does not establish an OCR fee or a working-day extension.
Keep the appointment decision, prior eligibility statement, licence evidence, appointment and engagement communications, term and remuneration together. Confirm the live CAMIS event and official requirements when filing; the sources reviewed do not authenticate a universal current upload checklist or English-only acceptance. The CMA templates are internal supporting documents and do not guarantee OCR acceptance.
Sources: Companies Act sections 110-119, ministry PDF pages 130-137; 2081 amending Act sections 1(2), 7(8), PDF pages 1 and 15; OCR after-incorporation guidance, auditor section. The OCR general guidance must be read with the later statutory amendment.
English guide | Nepali guide | Company secretary appointment and statutory records
Sources and references
ICAN - Suspicious Transaction Reporting Guidance, December 2025
IRD - Income Tax Act 2058, consolidated through Finance Act 2082
Providing these references does not mean that the full contents of every linked document have been independently verified. Specific limits stated in this article continue to apply.