An unpaid cost: the three accrual-deduction conditions
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
An unpaid invoice can qualify before cash leaves the bank.
Apply all three conditions
Section 24(2)(a) deals with expenditure in a payment made in exchange for another person's payment. It requires an obligation to pay, a liability value that can be reasonably estimated, and receipt of the other person's payment. The Directive explains the last condition through goods or services received: payment is not confined to cash.
For an ordinary purchase, ask whether the supplier has delivered what creates the liability, who is entitled to payment, and whether the amount can be reasonably measured. An estimated amount is not automatically disqualified merely because the final invoice comes later. But an uncertain future commitment should not become a deduction merely by entering a provision in the ledger.
A timing answer is only one step
Where the clause(a) situation is not met, section 24(2)(b) treats expenditure as incurred when payment is made. A prepayment for unreceived services and an accrued charge for services already received therefore need different analysis. A general financial-statement provision is not interchangeable with an existing payable.
Even when expenditure is incurred, determine its proper tax treatment. Trading stock enters the section 15 computation; a computer may be a depreciable asset rather than an immediate operating expense. Sections 13 and 21 still test connection with taxable income and deduction restrictions. The timing rule cannot transform an otherwise disallowed or capital amount into a current expense.
Key points
- An obligation and a reasonable estimate are not enough without the required consideration.
- Timing does not override stock, capital or prohibited-expense rules.
Directive example 8.4.2: an undated credit purchase
Bikash Nepal Trading sells goods worth Rs 50,000 to Swarnim, payable after one month. Swarnim has received the goods, owes the identified supplier and can reliably determine the liability. The Directive treats expenditure as incurred on accrual without waiting a month. This establishes timing; any stock-cost treatment remains a separate step.
Current legal position
The Directive separately rejects the Rs 500,000 future gratuity provision in example 8.4.3 for FY 2080/81. Its assumptions and the historical court decision in the case box should not be turned into a blanket rule for every funded retirement contribution.
Shriram Sugar Mills Ltd v Inland Revenue Department, with connected tax-office appeal
Court: Supreme Court of Nepal
Citation: Decision 10338; 072-RB-0473 and 0474
Decision date: 2075/02/14
Issue: Deduction for a gratuity provision in FY 2062/63.
Holding: The company had provided the amount in its own accounts without establishing and funding the statutory gratuity fund; deduction was denied.
Relevance: An accounting provision alone did not establish deductible expenditure.
Limits: Historical Labour Rules 2050 facts; not current retirement-fund approval or an exhaustive later-status check.
Prepaid services: payment does not always create a current deduction
A payment can buy a future service rather than settle a current expense.
First determine what has been received
For accrual accounting, section 24(2)(a) requires the payment obligation, a reasonably estimable value and receipt of the other person's payment. The Directive explains that an amount for goods or services not yet received is prepaid expenditure, even if the supplier and the amount are known. Sending money before year-end does not itself establish that the service belongs in that year.
Identify the service period and what the provider has supplied. Rent for next year differs from an overdue charge for accommodation already supplied this year. A contract covering several periods requires an analysis of the services and the applicable obligation; the law does not prescribe one universal straight-line deduction for every multi-year contract.
Do not borrow the result from another accounting basis
Section 23 generally links a cash-basis deduction to payment. Section 22 determines who may or must use a particular basis. A company required to use accrual accounting cannot switch to cash for a large prepaid invoice and retain accrual for everything else. A permitted change of basis has its own approval and anti-duplication adjustment.
After timing, apply the expense's other rules. Stock, depreciable assets, prepaid insurance or a refundable security may raise different issues. A refundable amount is not necessarily an expense at all. Separately test business purpose, prohibited payments and any specific deduction conditions. Payment timing cannot remove those restrictions.
Key points
- Cash and accrual methods can put the same rent in different years.
- The correct method applies consistently; it is not chosen for each payment.
Directive examples 8.3.1 and 8.4.1: original 2080/81 rent comparison
Mohan Kasaju and Sons pays Rs 100,000 during 2080/81 for 2081/82 rent. The cash table deducts the payment; the accrual table excludes it. Conversely,2080/81 rent of Rs 90,000 was paid in 2079/80: the current cash table gives no new deduction, while the accrual table deducts Rs 90,000. These paired examples isolate accounting timing, not a free choice between methods.
Current legal position
Preserve the original timing illustration. Current deductibility, payment-method restrictions and the actual rights under a lease must still be applied independently. A prepaid amount must not be deducted again when the service is later received.