An involuntary disposal: replacement relief changes proceeds and cost

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

Replacement relief needs the same kind of asset within one year and a written request.

Test the event and the replacement

Section 46 is not a general exemption for selling an asset and buying another. The original disposal must be involuntary, replacement must be of the same kind, ownership must be acquired within one year after disposal, and the person must request application in writing. The period runs from disposal, not merely to the end of an income year.

The Directive explains that replacement can fall in the next income year. The choice must be addressed in the first disposal-year return; failure to acquire the replacement within the statutory year can require amendment of that earlier assessment. A plan to replace does not itself complete the conditions.

Carry the tax base through the calculation

For an asset, start with its net outgoings immediately before disposal. Deemed disposal proceeds equal that base plus any excess of actual proceeds over replacement expenditure. Replacement outgoings equal the old base plus any excess of replacement expenditure over actual disposal proceeds. This can defer a gain into the replacement cost rather than eliminate it forever.

Liabilities have a separate section 46(2) calculation. From old net incomings, subtract any excess of settlement expenditure over new-liability receipts for the deemed settlement outgoing. New-liability incomings add any excess of those receipts over settlement expenditure. Do not use the asset formula unchanged.

For a qualifying substitution of entity interests, Rule 16 requires an application for Department approval. A merger instruction or commercial exchange alone is not that approval. This route must also be distinguished from any separate current compensation exemption or historical business-merger relief.

Key points

  • Cash not reinvested can leave a current gain.
  • The replacement tax cost may be below the amount actually paid.

Directive example22.13.2: equal compensation and replacement cost

Goparma Ltd loses an insured building in a fire. Its opening depreciation basis is Rs 5000000; insurance compensation is Rs 8000000. The example offers several replacement costs. In the Rs 8000000 column, a new building is constructed within one year and section 46 is chosen. Deemed disposal proceeds and replacement outgoings are Rs 5000000, with no difference to recognise in that column. The resulting depreciation basis is Rs 5000000, not the Rs 8000000 cash construction cost. No income year is specified.

Source: IRD Income Tax Directive Fifth Amendment2081

Current legal position

Depreciable assets still need their Schedule 2 pool calculation. The same-kind test, date and actual replacement amount determine relief; receiving compensation alone is insufficient.

Sources and references