An insurance payout: distinguish investment gain from accident compensation

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

Identify what the insurer is paying before calculating withholding.

Start with the policy and the event

A maturity payment and an accident claim can come from the same insurer while producing different income-tax results. Obtain the policy, premium history and settlement statement. Identify whether the payment is an investment-insurance benefit, compensation for physical injury, replacement of business income or another receipt. The insurer’s name and the payment’s size do not settle that classification.

Section 62 defines investment-insurance gain by comparing the insurance payment with premiums paid for that insurance. Section 88(2)(b) requires 5 percent withholding on the gain paid by a resident person. Do not apply 5 percent to the whole maturity proceeds or deduct only the final year’s premium. The policy’s stated sum insured is also different from the actual payout and accumulated premium cost.

Compensation needs its own analysis

Section 31 excludes compensation for a resident natural person’s physical injury from a personal accident from income. It also prevents claiming a section 51 medical credit for treatment of that injury. Compensation received because of a natural person’s death has a separate exclusion. These provisions should not be extended automatically to compensation replacing business income or deductible business expenditure.

Keep the claim approval and its breakdown. Where a settlement contains several components, establish what each replaces before deciding the tax result. A generic ledger entry saying insurance receipt conceals this distinction.

Key points

  • For investment insurance, the relevant gain is the payout exceeding premiums paid.
  • Personal physical-injury compensation has a separate statutory treatment.

Keep the payout evidence

Ask for the gain calculation, premiums recognised, tax deducted and withholding certificate. Reconcile the gross payout, tax and net bank receipt. Investment-insurance gain paid by a resident insurer falls within the final-withholding framework; a foreign insurer’s payment instead needs the separate section 62 income-inclusion analysis.

Directive examples 16.2.37-16.2.38: maturity and personal accident

Purnata’s policy has a stated sum insured of Rs 800,000. She pays Rs 40,000 annually and total premiums reach Rs 600,000. The maturity payout is Rs 1,200,000. The Directive calculates gain Rs 600,000, withholding Rs 30,000 and net payment Rs 1,170,000. No income year is specified.

Sajag Sapkota breaks his arm in the third policy year. He receives Rs 50,000 compensation after paying Rs 20,000 premiums. The Directive treats this personal-accident compensation as outside tax, rather than taxing a supposed Rs 30,000 investment gain.

Source: IRD Income Tax Directives2066 Fifth Amendment2081

Current legal position

The current FY 2083/84 notice retains 5 percent for investment-insurance gain. The new 20 percent rule concerns a resident natural-person insurance agent’s service fee or commission, a different transaction. Keep policy proceeds and agent remuneration separate.

Sources and references