After an ownership change: which old losses and credits stop carrying?
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
A section 57 change can restrict much more than ordinary loss carry-forward.
Identify the boundary before moving attributes
Section 57(1) concerns the specified 50%-or-more ownership change compared with the preceding three-year ownership. Its calculation rules and current exceptions must be applied first. A commercial share transfer is not automatically proof that every restriction operates. Once the statutory change applies,57(3) treats the before-and-after portions of that income year as separate income years.
Section 57(2) blocks pre-change interest carried under 14(3), pre-change 20 losses, and carrying a post-change loss back to a pre-change income year under 20(4). The restrictions therefore work across the change boundary in both directions; they are not merely a shorter expiry period for one loss balance.
Separate the other restricted amounts
The list also covers specified 24(4) adjustments to amounts/expenses accounted for before the change;25(1)(b) amounts whose receipt right is later abandoned or whose debt claim is written off; pre-change disposal losses used against later disposal incomings; and specified insurance premiums recognised before the change but refunded afterwards. Each has its own statutory condition.
Finally, pre-change foreign income tax cannot be carried forward under 71(3) after the change. An unused foreign-tax balance is therefore different from cash paid to IRD or an ordinary current withholding certificate. Do not cancel every balance called a 'tax credit' without identifying the particular statutory restriction.
The split periods and deemed-disposal consequences must agree with the attribute analysis. Leaving a balance in the accounting ledger does not make it tax-usable by the post-change period. Conversely, the rule should not be enlarged into a prohibition on every expense incurred after an acquisition. Finance 2083’s new exceptions and deletion of 47 A require the actual transaction and applicable dates, not a merger label alone.
Key points
- Pre-change and post-change periods are treated as separate income years.
- First establish that the current trigger applies and no statutory exception protects the transaction.
Directive 13.10.7: original 2079 change date
Danfe’s ownership changes on 15 Chaitra 2079. The Directive separates 1 Shrawan 2079 through 15 Chaitra 2079 from 16 Chaitra 2079 through Ashadh-end 2080 for return purposes. The example shows the boundary; it does not supply a monetary tax-loss or credit balance to deduct.
Current legal position
Trace each restricted attribute to its own provision and side of the change. The old owner’s accounting balance is not an automatic post-change tax deduction.
Section 57(2)(gha) pre-change accrual adjustments
Before: The pre-change reference was to section 24(4)(ka).
Change: Finance 2080 removes the words referring to clause(ka), leaving the section 24(4) reference in that part of the restriction.
Instrument: Finance 2080,44(7), PDF 259.
Effective date: 2080 Shrawan 1 under 1(2), PDF 2;44 is outside the immediate list.
Practical effect: Use the amended cross-reference when identifying pre-change amounts subject to the post-change adjustment restriction.
Section 57(1) specified startup/private-equity fund exception
Before: The retainedAct through 2080 did not contain the startup venture-capital/private-equity capital-increase proviso.
Change: Finance 2081 adds the proviso for those funds where existing shareholders/partners retain their share numbers and capital while new shareholders/partners join and capital increases.
Instrument: Finance 2081,36(6), PDF 243.
Effective date: 2081 Shrawan 1 under 1(2), PDF 2;36(6) is not the immediately commencing 36(14).
Practical effect: Do not project that exception into earlier years or apply it to every ordinary-company capital increase. Finance 2083 later replaces/extends its wording as separately boxed.
Section 57(1) exceptions and former 47 A
Before: The 57(1) proviso addressed specified startup venture-capital/private-equity capital increases. Former 47 A separately gave qualifying financial/insurance mergers relief from specified 57 restrictions.
Change: Finance 2083 replaces the proviso, retaining the specified funding case and adding involuntary interests passing to legal heirs because a beneficiary dies, and the specified consequential ownership change in another resident entity. The replacement says section 57 does not apply in those cases. It separately deletes 47 A.
Instrument: Finance 2083,57(10)-(11), PDF 206.
Effective date: 2083 Shrawan 1 under 1(2), PDF 2.
Practical effect: Establish an actual current 57 trigger and exceptions before cutting off attributes. Do not rely on the adjacent old 47 A chapter as a presently available blanket merger concession. Historical/transitional rights need their own applicable instrument.
Several share changes over three years: does section 57 trigger?
The comparison is a moving three-year ownership test, not just one transfer form.
Compare ownership, not merely one transaction
Section 57(1) addresses a change of at least 50% against the ownership within the preceding three-year comparison. The Directive considers successive transactions within that moving period. A first transfer below 50% does not immunise a later transfer merely because neither agreement individually sells a majority.
Equally, repeated transfers must be connected to the statutory ownership comparison rather than mechanically adding every trade forever. Establish the relevant earlier ownership, later ownership, dates and actual underlying interests. An increase in nominal capital is not automatically a change in who owns the entity.
Apply the holder-inclusion rule precisely
Section 57(1 A)(a) includes ownership held by shareholders or partners holding at least 1% of total ownership. Paragraph (b) also includes a holding below 1% where its holder is associated with a shareholder or partner holding more than 1%. The latter wording is more than 1%, not at least 1%.
It is therefore unsafe either to count every dispersed small holding automatically or to exclude every sub-1% interest. The relevant association and ownership facts determine inclusion. Do not replace this calculation with an unsupported count of share certificates or a commercial label such as family transfer.
Finance 2081 added the specified startup venture-capital/private-equity capital-increase proviso. Finance 2083 replaces it with the stated funding, involuntary death-to-legal-heir and consequential resident-entity ownership exceptions. The current replacement disapplies section 57 in its qualifying cases. An ordinary company’s capital raising or later voluntary sale by an heir is not automatically protected.
Key points
- The statute specifies which small holdings enter the calculation.
- Apply current exceptions before imposing deemed disposal or cutting off tax attributes.
Directive 13.10.1: two transfers within the period
Company Gya (ज्ञ) has holdings of 30% and 35% by companies Ka and Kha. Ka sells its 30% at Chaitra-end 2079: the source does not yet apply section 57. Kha sells its 35% on 15 Chaitra 2080. The source then identifies 65% change within three years. The dates and distinct holders are part of that example; 30% + 35% = 65% is not a rule to add unrelated or repeated trades without an ownership comparison.
Current legal position
Once the actual trigger and exceptions are settled, deemed values, split income years and restricted attributes need their separate computations. This article establishes the gate; it does not cancel every old balance merely because a share transfer occurred.