Administrative VAT review: deadlines, deposits and the Qurex judgment

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

The ordinary application runs from notice of the assessment decision.

Preserve the service date and grounds

Section 31क(1) allows a person dissatisfied with the tax officer's assessment decision to apply to the Director General within 30 days after receiving notice. Keep the decision, service evidence and the calculation of the filing deadline together. An informal discussion or a letter that does not constitute the required application will not preserve that remedy. Identify the disputed periods, facts, statutory grounds and relief sought, with the supporting records.

If the deadline is missed, subsection (2) allows an extension application within seven days after expiry, explaining the cause. If that cause is reasonable, the Director General may extend 30 days from the original expiry. This is discretionary, not an automatic extra month or seven additional days for filing the main review. Record the extension decision.

Reconcile the required payment

Subsection (6) requires payment of undisputed assessed tax and deposit of one quarter of disputed tax. Under subsection (7), qualifying excess amounts already deposited before applying reduce the remaining amount to the extent they cover that requirement. Trace the actual vouchers and office allocation. Do not assume unused input-credit balances or an internal journal satisfy the deposit. Qurex concerns fair treatment of an already registered application with a disputed deposit defect; it is not a universal credit-for-cash rule.

Use the current departmental submission arrangement and retain a receipt, document list and proof of any representative's authority. The Directive discusses grounds, evidence and payment proof. A general objection saying only that the assessment is unfair leaves the actual calculation and legal issues unexplained.

Key points

  • Pay undisputed tax and deposit one quarter of disputed tax, subject to qualifying prior excess deposits.
  • A credit ledger and a review deposit are different; preserve evidence and filing acknowledgement.

Track the decision and next stage

The Director General must decide within 60 days of application. If the applicant's grounds are established, subsection (3) permits reasoned cancellation and a reassessment direction. If no decision arrives within that period, subsection (5) permits Tribunal appeal; delay is not an automatic merits victory. The further appeal and its deposit are a separate stage.

Subsection (8) keeps the review deposit from refund until final disposal. Section 25(1ग) separately addresses requested refund of surplus after a court judgment and revised assessment implementing it. Review does not itself stop section 26 interest. Track the actual decision, payment allocation and any interim order.

C.M. & Associates illustration: the review amount

Assume undisputed assessed tax of Rs 100,000 and disputed tax of Rs 400,000, with no qualifying prior excess deposit. The review requirement is Rs 100,000 plus one quarter of Rs 400,000, totalling Rs 200,000. This tax-only illustration does not calculate a Tribunal deposit or invent a claim that input credit is money already deposited.

Illustration by C.M. & Associates, based on the legal provisions discussed in this article. It is not an official IRD example or a court decision.

Current legal position

The ordinary 31क procedure remains distinct from time-limited settlement or waiver schemes. Preserve the deadline while checking the actual current route. A historic fairness judgment does not waive today's filing, proof or deposit requirements.

Section 25(1ग): surplus review deposit following court implementation

Before: The checked Act through Finance 2081 did not contain subsection (1ग). Section 31क(8) separately withheld refund until final disposal.

Change: A surplus of amounts deposited under section 31क(6) can be refunded on request after a court judgment and revised assessment made in implementing that judgment.

Instrument: Finance Act 2082 section 35(5), original PDF pages 12-13.

Effective date: Immediately under section 1(2), which expressly includes section 35; Gazette 2082/03/30, PDF page 1.

Practical effect: This is a conditional surplus-refund route, not immediate refund of every disputed deposit or restoration of unused credit.

Inland Revenue Office, Bhaktapur v Qurex Pharmaceuticals Pvt Ltd

Court: Supreme Court of Nepal, Division Bench

Citation: NKP 2077, issue 8, decision 10551; 072-RB-0154

Decision date: 2076/05/16

Issue: Dismissal of an already registered administrative review over a disputed deposit, alongside a historical credit-reversal/penalty dispute.

Holding: Paragraph 6 found it unjust to dismiss the registered application without a reasonable opportunity to supply additional deposit when credit could not count as deposit. The Court also rejected the unsupported penalty on the particular chronology and statutory offence grounds and upheld the Tribunal result.

Relevance: Keep deposit evidence and any defect/opportunity-to-cure correspondence; identify the actual procedural decision.

Limits: Tax period 2064 Shrawan-2066 Baisakh and historical law. No blanket deadline extension, automatic acceptance of input credit as cash, universal penalty amnesty or current deposit waiver. Underlying Tribunal result reported in the SC judgment; no separately retrieved Tribunal full text.

Read the official decision

Sources and references
  • IRD VAT Directives 2069, third amendment 2080

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Chapter 11, paragraphs 11.1-11.2.3, original PDF/printed pages 179-182; application grounds/evidence and representation discussion, pages 180-181.

  • VAT Act 2052 through Finance Act 2082

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Section 31क(1)-(8), PDF pages 34-35; section 25(1ग), PDF page 27; section 26, PDF pages 28-29; prior deposit wording endnote 176, PDF page 132.

  • VAT Act 2052 through Finance Act 2081

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Section 25 before new subsection (1ग), PDF page 27; section 31क, PDF pages 34-35.

  • Finance Act 2082, Nepal Law Commission text published by FCGO

    Authority / publisher: Government of Nepal - official legislation

    Relevant information: Section 35(5), PDF pages 12-13 adds section 25(1ग); immediate section 1(2), PDF page 1, Gazette 2082/03/30.

  • Finance Act 2083, Nepal Gazette

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Section 55 VAT overlay, PDF pages 23-26; no amendment to section 31क or 25(1ग). Temporary settlement schemes are separate from this ordinary procedural guide.

  • VAT (Twenty-eighth Amendment) Rules 2083, Nepal Gazette

    Authority / publisher: Department of Printing - Nepal Gazette

    Relevant information: Full amendment Rules 2-8, PDF pages 2-3; no new administrative-review deposit or deadline introduced.

  • Supreme Court decision 10551, Qurex Pharmaceuticals

    Authority / publisher: Supreme Court of Nepal - Nepal Kanoon Patrika

    Relevant information: Actual reasoning paragraphs 4-7, especially paragraph 6 deposit opportunity; operative paragraph 8. Decision 2076/05/16, NKP 2077 issue 8.