A tax appeal succeeds: what may the office assess again?
Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026
A reduction on a settled issue and an order for fresh inquiry have different effects.
Read what the decision actually settled
Section 101(5) prevents the Department from amending an assessment to the extent that the Revenue Tribunal or another competent court has amended it or reduced the assessed tax. Its proviso allows amendment where a fresh investigation has been ordered. A final reduction and a remand therefore have different consequences.
A direction to exclude specified receipts leaves those exclusions central to implementation. A direction to determine the remaining amount leaves that calculation open. Read the operative order with its reasons; the words 'appeal allowed' or 'assessment quashed' alone do not establish that no tax can ever be assessed for the year.
Give effect to the actual order
For an administrative-review decision, act through the decision and the applicable review powers. Do not describe every internal decision as a court determination protected by section 101(5). Directive 26.7 discusses implementing Director-General, Tribunal and court decisions, including decisions that have become final.
The Directive instructs that an amendment required by such a final decision should be completed within one year of receiving its copy. That is the Directive’s implementation instruction, distinct from the ordinary statutory reassessment period. Finance 2083 reduces the ordinary section 101(3) period to three years; it does not remove the settled-issue/remand distinction.
Where a fresh amended assessment is made, section 101(6) requires grounds and 15 days to produce explanatory evidence. The section 102 notice must identify the resulting assessment, computation, unpaid amount and challenge route. The new total must also give effect to relevant payments and credits; quashing an earlier demand is not a reason to charge an already paid amount twice.
If implementation goes beyond the remand or reinstates an exclusion the order rejected, that is a specific issue to challenge. Any further appeal or stay must be established from its actual order; this article does not certify that the example judgment is unappealed.
Key points
- The operative order defines what remains open.
- A remand is not a blanket exemption or permission to restore the same demand unchanged.
Directive 26.7: final decision and implementation
The Directive distinguishes a decision that is no longer pending or capable of being pending in court from an unresolved challenge. Its one-year instruction runs from receipt of the decision copy, not from the original income year. It contains no numbered monetary example for this point.
Current legal position
Apply the binding order’s actual scope and legal status. Ordinary three-year reassessment wording does not by itself decide a historical remand or its transitional application.
Section 101(3), ordinary reassessment period
Before: Ordinary period was four years from the specified statutory reference date.
Change: Four years is replaced by three years. Section 101(5) protection for the court/Tribunal-settled extent and its remand proviso are not replaced.
Instrument: Finance 2083, section 57(23), PDF 211.
Effective date: 2083 Shrawan 1 under section 1(2), PDF 2.
Practical effect: Keep ordinary limitation separate from the actual scope and status of a binding decision; the change is not permission to reopen a settled reduction. Historical/transitional dates still matter.
Detecon Asia-Pacific Ltd v Inland Revenue Office Lalitpur
Court: Revenue Tribunal Kathmandu
Citation: Decision 298, FY 2078/79; 076-RB-0019; majority paragraphs 13-15/PDF 6-8
Decision date: 2079/03/06
Issue: Scope of reassessment after remand
Holding: The majority ordered a fresh withholding assessment after excluding identified actual head-office reimbursements; it did not exempt every overhead payment.
Relevance: Implement the specified exclusions and reassess the remaining amount.
Limits: Historical FY2070/71 facts. The accounting-member dissent concerns appeal security and is not the majority order. Later appeal/finality not exhaustively checked.