A liability is settled or forgiven: calculate the disposal result

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

A liability is disposed of when the person is freed from its burden.

Identify the discharge and amounts

Section 40(2) includes settlement, cancellation, release, termination and merger into another asset/liability in disposal of a liability. An accounting reclassification alone does not prove that the legal burden has ended. Conversely, a release can matter even if no fresh cash enters the borrower’s bank account.

For 37, the gain is incomings exceeding outgoings; the same formula applies to assets and liabilities. What differs is the direction of the relevant amounts. Section 39 includes receipts for assuming the liability, while 38 includes qualifying expenditure relating to it and its disposal. Applying a buyer’s asset-cost model to a borrower’s liability can therefore reverse the result.

Prevent duplication and test special rules

Section 39 excludes specified exempt, final-withholding or otherwise income-included amounts from the disposal incomings. Section 38 excludes amounts deductible in determining income to the stated extent. An amount should not become taxable income or deductible expense twice merely because the liability also has a disposal working. Interest classification remains a separate question.

Where a liability is transferred to an associate, discharged through merger of rights, or retained after a deemed disposal,45,47 or 41 may prescribe the amounts. Do not assume that every change in face value is a free-standing loan-forgiveness gain. The taxable business/investment connection and source/loss rules still matter.

A lender writing off its asset and a borrower being released from a liability are not one identical tax event. The lender’s allowable bad-debt treatment cannot simply be copied as the borrower’s deduction. Establish the actual discharge, then reconcile the statutory incomings and outgoings.

Key points

  • Borrowing receipts and settlement expenditure have different roles in the gain calculation.
  • A creditor’s loss and a debtor’s gain are separate taxpayers’ questions.

Directive 22.8.2: original retained liability

Kaman issues 15% debentures raising Rs 20,000,000. On 2065/8/11, the example assumes a 57 event and market value Rs 21,000,000: the liability’s deemed-disposal loss is Rs 1,000,000. It is settled for Rs 20,000,000 at Ashadh-end 2068. Against reset incomings of Rs 21,000,000, the later settlement gives Rs 1,000,000 gain. The example illustrates why a liability’s reset is not an asset purchase cost.

Source: Income Tax Directives2066,Fifth Amendment2081

Current legal position

These are historical source assumptions, not current borrowing or withholding rates. A taxable disposal result depends on the applicable event and amounts, not the accounting label loan.

Sources and references