A false tax statement: identify the shortfall before charging 50% or 100%

Updated by: C.M. & Associates, Chartered Accountants | Latest update: 2 November 2026

The charge is based on tax understated, not the gross omitted receipt.

Establish the statement and its tax effect

Section 120 covers false or misleading information supplied to the Department, including failure to disclose required information or removing information so the statement becomes misleading. Its explanation extends beyond the annual return to applications, notices, complaints, statements, other documents, answers and specified information supplied through another person.

Identify what was incorrect or omitted and the tax reduction caused by it. A difference between two tax computations does not by itself answer every element. The Kumari Bank case illustrates the need to establish the actual false-statement basis in its particular payroll setting.

Apply the correct charge and distinguish assistance

If the statement became false or misleading by mistake, without intentional or reckless conduct, section 120(a) charges 50% of the resulting tax shortfall. If intentional or reckless conduct caused it, paragraph(b) charges 100%. The base is the tax shortfall, not automatically the invoice value, insurance receipt or disallowed expense.

Section 121 separately charges an assistant who intentionally or recklessly helps, encourages or advises a person committing an offence under the Act. Its fee is 100% of the tax underpaid by that person. An adviser’s role and conduct must therefore be established rather than inferred merely from the existence of a professional engagement.

Section 122 requires the Department to assess the charge and give written reasons, amount, calculation and challenge information. Its separate calculation and notice rules matter. Paying an administrative charge does not itself release a person from a separately applicable criminal liability under Chapter 23; neither does this charge amount to a criminal conviction.

Key points

  • A misleading omission can matter as much as an incorrect statement.
  • The mental-state distinction affects the percentage; the statutory statement trigger still matters.

Authentic ABC Company illustration: FY 2080/81

The Directive describes ABC Company omitting an insurance receipt of Rs 1,000,000. On evidence establishing deliberate concealment, the example applies 25% tax, producing Rs 250,000 additional tax, and a section 120(b) charge of Rs 250,000. These are the source’s historical assumptions. The charge is 100% of the Rs 250,000 tax shortfall, not 100% of the Rs 1,000,000 receipt.

Source: Income Tax Directives 2066, Fifth Amendment 2081

Current legal position

Apply the actual statement, conduct and shortfall. The historical 25% company computation is not a universal current rate for every taxpayer or receipt.

Large Taxpayer Office v Kumari Bank Ltd

Court: Supreme Court of Nepal

Citation: Decision 11026;077-RB-0062; paragraphs 5-6

Decision date: 2078/11/16

Issue: Section 120(a) fee where payroll details were not hidden

Holding: In this payroll case, the Court upheld reversal of the 120(a) fee where relevant details were not concealed; the withholding difference did not establish the charged false-statement basis.

Relevance: Identify the statutory false statement or misleading omission, not merely a tax difference.

Limits: Historical FY2067/68; not immunity for every disclosed error or a current payroll-relief ruling. Later history not exhaustively checked.

Read the official decision

Unpaid tax and criminal liability: why reasonable cause matters

A tax debt and a criminal charge are separate legal questions.

Read the condition before the sanction

Section 123 applies to a person who, without reasonable cause, fails to deposit tax by the prescribed time. The available punishment is a fine of Rs 5,000 to Rs 30,000, imprisonment of one to three months, or both. The reasonable-cause condition is part of the provision, not a discretionary sentence added after every unpaid account is automatically treated as criminal.

Identify the tax payable, the prescribed due date, the nonpayment and the circumstances relied on as reasonable cause. The section does not define a universal list of acceptable excuses. It would be misleading to promise that lack of cash, a pending refund or disagreement with an officer always satisfies the condition.

Keep debt collection and prosecution distinct

Section 111 permits the Department to bring a tax-recovery suit in the relevant District Court where tax is not paid by the due date. That collection route seeks the debt. Section 123 is a punishment provision with its own condition. A person should not be told that an ordinary collection letter already proves guilt or imposes imprisonment.

Section 119 interest can also arise from overdue tax. Interest compensates under its statutory calculation; it does not replace the section 123 inquiry. Paying interest is not, by itself, proof that a criminal offence was committed. Conversely, payment of an administrative charge does not automatically remove separately applicable criminal exposure, as section 122(3) explains.

A section 110A instalment permission is another distinct result. It addresses collection time under the approved terms. Do not turn an application for instalments into an admission that no reasonable cause existed, or assume that merely submitting one cancels an existing criminal proceeding. The applicable approval and actual procedural position matter.

Key points

  • Section 123 expressly refers to failure to pay without reasonable cause.
  • Collection, late-payment interest and punishment have different statutory bases.

Directive criminal-provision discussion

The Directive reproduces the section 123 nonpayment provision separately from the recovery and interest provisions. Its trigger includes nonpayment without reasonable cause. The fine/imprisonment alternatives belong to that punishment rule, not to every outstanding ledger balance.

Source: Income Tax Directives 2066, Fifth Amendment 2081

Current legal position

The checked provision requires its actual elements and lawful criminal process. This article gives no conclusion about guilt or reasonable cause in an individual case.

Sources and references
  • Income Tax Act 2058 through Finance 2082

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: Sections 120-122, PDF 148-150; Sections 123, PDF 150;111, PDF 139;119, PDF 147;122(3), PDF 149

  • Income Tax Directives 2066, Fifth Amendment 2081

    Authority / publisher: Inland Revenue Department

    Relevant information: 29.2.4, ABCCompanyillustration, printed 612/PDF 630; assistance 29.2.5/example 29.2.7, PDF 631; Chapter 29 criminaldiscussion, PDF 636-637

  • SupremeCourtDecision 11026

    Authority / publisher: Supreme Court of Nepal - Nepal Kanoon Patrika

    Relevant information: 2078/11/16;077-RB-0062; paras 5-6, especiallyoperative 6